I think this one should be fun. I'll go first. Remember, Nothing from your top 50 is allowed, a gentleman's agreement is in place. Hopefully many of you won't have listed your top 100 which would make this very easy and yes this is basically asking what your number 51-56 games are but sush, have fun searching the noggin, net or lists for your five. 

1. Uncharted 2

2. Dust an Elysian tail

3. Transistor 

4. Fire Emblem: Three houses

5. Metal Gear Solid 3

I've combed through as many games as I can stomach for this from my records, I'd bet there are some I missed that would fit better but from what I turned up, these be my five in order. Even though it's not my top, Dust is what stands out the most as the most fun, probably cause of the amazing Platinum it had. This would leave MGS3 40 rungs below my other MGS entries, something I hope MGS3 Delta reconciles, I'd love to see it closer up there with MGS 1, 2 and 5. 

Now that I think on it, I'd rather have this thread be, Your top five games below a your 7/10 opinion. Ah...one for again.

I think I'll just list 5 games that catch my eye on the shelf that are in some particular way good games but I don't expect to ever put in my top 50.
(Though that may not be true because I plan to make my future lists from different perspectives.)

Total Overdose (PC)
Xpand Rally (PC)
LiberoGrande (PS1)
Ninja Assault (PS2)
Mafia 1 (PC)

Can't stop, have to make it 10.

Prey (PC, the first one)
Just Cause 1 (PC)
Nocturne (PC)
Gun (PS2)
Betrayal at Krondor/Betrayal in Antara/Return to Krondor (PC, any of the "trilogy" would do for different reasons, I suppose the last is best if I had to pick one)

So basically games 51-55 from my top games:

51. Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity
52. Octopath Traveler
53. Spider-Man 2
54. Final Fantasy XI
55. Neverwinter Nights

Not necesarily my "top 5 after my top 50" but its 5 games I quite like that are not in my top 50:

1. TLOZ Tears of the Kingdom
2. Dead Space
3. Persona 5 Royale
4. SMW 2 Yoshis Island
5. Star Fox 64

There are a lot of games that are just outside my top 50 that I consider more or less equal. If I'd have to pick five, it'd be something like:

1. Final Fantasy XII
2. Portal 2
3. Octopath Traveler 2
4. Enslaved: Odyssey to the West
5. Tales of Xillia

Okay. This was abbetter idea in my head. Scrap this thread. Let it die people, let it die.