Your top 5 games but you can't choose anything from your top 50.

[Kaunisto]

I think I'll just list 5 games that catch my eye on the shelf that are in some particular way good games but I don't expect to ever put in my top 50.
(Though that may not be true because I plan to make my future lists from different perspectives.)

Total Overdose (PC)
Xpand Rally (PC)
LiberoGrande (PS1)
Ninja Assault (PS2)
Mafia 1 (PC)

Can't stop, have to make it 10.

Prey (PC, the first one)
Just Cause 1 (PC)
Nocturne (PC)
Gun (PS2)
Betrayal at Krondor/Betrayal in Antara/Return to Krondor (PC, any of the "trilogy" would do for different reasons, I suppose the last is best if I had to pick one)