Here are the top video game adaptations by Rotten Tomatoes score (only including adaptations with a significant number of reviews):
Films
- Sonic 3- 86% (tie)
- Werewolves Within- 86% (tie)
- Angry Birds 2- 72%
- Sonic 2- 69%
- Detective Pikachu- 68%
- Sonic 1- 63%
- Super Mario Bros (2023)- 59%
- Mortal Kombat (2021)- 54%
- Tomb Raider (2018)- 52%
- Rampage- 51%
And just to compare to some of the recent TV series adaptations of video games (sorry if I missed some, couldn't find an easy list of video game tv adaptations like I could for movies, so I had to search for the ones I could think of off the top of my head):
- The Last of Us- 96%
- Castlevania: Nocturne- 96%
- Fallout- 94%
- Dragon Age: Absolution- 92%
- Halo- 80% (average of season 1 and 2)
- Cuphead- 75%
- Knuckles- 75%
- Tomb Raider: The Legend of Lara Croft- 73%
- Like A Dragon: Yakuza- 67%
- Twisted Metal- 67%