Doesn't have to be a game that came out this year, you just have had to finished it. Let's use this thread as a compass to find some good titles to play. If you wanna elaborate and explain your score on the game please do. I have had a particularly great and productive year. Gonna rip my list from another thread:

1. Tales of Arise  - 9/10

2. Neir Replicant  - 8/10

3. Project CARS 2 - 6/10

4. Dave the Diver  - 10/10

5. Dirt 4  - 9/10

6. Cat Quest  - 7/10

7. 13 sentinels Aegis Rim  - 8/10

8. Elden Ring + DLC - 10/10  (Platinum)

9. Sekiro: Shadows Die twice - 10/10    (Platinum)

10. Bloodborne - 10/10   (Platinum)

11. Hogwarts Legacy - 9/10

12. Lies of P  - 6/10

13. Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty - 7.5/10  (Platinum)

14. Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon - 6.5/10

15. Spiderman: Miles Morales - 7/10

16. Nioh 2 - 9/10

17. Vampire survivors - 9/10

My particular highlights were Dave the Diver, Tales of Arise and revisting the soulsborne games along with Vampire survivors and my time spent Rallying in Dirt 4. All are easily or close to 10's, not perfect but exceptionally good. 

Games is 2023:

1. Granturismo 7 *55 hours - (9/10)

2. Monster Hunter Rise [HR rank 100] *70 hours - (10/10)

3. Metal Gear solid *10 hours - (10/10)

4. Metal Gear Sold 2 *12 hours - (10/10)

5. Diablo 4 *250 hours - (10/10)   (Platinum)

Dragons Dogma 2 - 7/10 

Eiyuden Chronicles - 7/10 

Baldurs Gate 3 - 8/10

Sea of Stars - 6/10

Chained Echoes - 8/10

Unicorn Overlord - 9/10

Octopath II - 6/10

Granblue fantasy relink - 6/10

Elden Ring SOTE - 9/10 

Kena Bridge of spirits - 7/10

FFVII Rebirth - 9/10 

Lies of P - 7/10 

Stellar Blade - 7/10 

These are the new games I cleared this year. Other games ive cleared have been replayed. I dunno how many hours I put into each. 

Mortal Kombat 1 - 5/10
Lies of P - 8/10
Persona 3 Reload - 7/10
FF VII Rebirth - This is hard. Part of it is 10/10 and part of it is 3/10. I'll say 8. Minigame grind is rough. Otherwise a 9.
Stellar Blade - 7/10
Spider Man 2 - I got bored within 3 hours. So similar to Miles Morales and the first one. Dont think I could properly rank it.
Elden Ring/Shadow of Erdtreee - Played through from the beginning, then did the DLC. 10/10. The last boss was dumb though.
Baletro - I suck. For sucking so bad 6/10
Returnal - Love the gameplay, hate the loops - 7/10
Black Myth Wukong - 9/10
AstroBot - Only a few hours in, but so far 7/10

I'm only counting games I started this year rather than going back and beating.

No Rest for the Wicked - 8/10 (although I will have to return as the game is still in Early Access)

Spider-Man 2 - 7/10 (my enjoyment for the game has cooled down as time has gone on)

Star Wars Dark Forces Remaster - 9/10

Dragon's Dogma 2 - 7/10

Marathon 1-3 (I'll give all 3 a 6/10. Need to be heavily modded to really enjoy them. Still cool to see old school Bungie return)

Mullet Mad Jack - 8/10

Selaco - 8/10

Hellblade 2 - 6/10

Contra: Operation Galuga - 7/10

Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door - 10/10 (still as perfect as it was 20 years ago!)

Kunitsu-Gami: Path of the Goddess - 10/10

Cygni: All Guns Blazing - 4/10 (pretty visuals, mediocre shmup)

Age of Mythology: Retold - 9/10

Warhammer 40K: Space Marine 2 - 9/10

Astro Bot - 9/10 (Just finished all 5 main galaxies and will be starting my 100% run on the Lost Galaxy)

Unicorn Overlord - 9/10 (Great personal introduction to Vanillaware!)

Same as you with Spiderman in Miles Morales. It's like you need many years in between those titles to appreciate them again but...

Kunitsu-gami... 10/10? Wow. How so? Points for uniqueness or is it really that good. You scored it higher than Unicorn Overlord... elaborate please 😃 

I bet everyone feels the same as spiderman as us, years in between titles isn't enough go get rid of the fatigue. I had 5 years between SM and Miles Morales (got bored at launch) and I still felt slight fatigue. Couldn't even think about SM2 until like 2028 at least. I hope Insomniac does a new titles between now and SM3. I wonder could they get away with putting SM in a new city but even then, way to much fatigue even if they opened up New Jersey and the tri state area you can only play so much spiderman. 

And woah, 7/10 for Astrobot. That's against the grain. How did you feel about Lies of P's penultimate boss Lasaxia? I knocked a point off cause of that and some other bosses getting hard, next boss is a hit try kill, next boss is hard, next on one try etc. Cause of the difficulty curve but I found Lasaxia to be truly atrocious in difficulty design. 

Only counting new completions and not replays.

9.8/10 Half Life Alyx

9.5/10 Baldur’s Gate 3

9/10 Metroid Prime Remastered

8.5/10 Goodbye Volcano High

8.2/10 Caravan Sandwitch

8/10 Pacific Drive

8/10 Sheepy: A Short Adventure

8/10 Cocoon

7.5/10 Rise of the Rōnin

7/10 Final Fantasy 16

7/10 Viewfinder

7/10 Botany Manor

7/10 Persona 3 Reload

6.5/10 Valiant Hearts 

6.5/10 Return of the Obra Dinn

6.5/10 Robocop: Rogue City

6/10 Spider-Man 2

6/10 Xenoblade Chronicles 2 

6/10 Heavy Rain

5.5/10 Jusant 

4.5/10 Dragons Dogma 2

2.5/10 Unpacking

1/10 Frog Detective

I score them from a 1 to 100 score (i.e. 80 being a 8)

NS
Mario Kart 8 Deluxe - 98
Final Fantasy VI Pixel Remaster - 96
Final Fantasy VII - 94
Dragon Ball FighterZ - 85
Devil May Cry - 80
Dragon Quest I - 69

PS4
Kingdom Hearts Birth By Sleep Final Mix - 99
Ratchet & Clank (2016) - 93
Tekken 2 - 86
The King of Fighters 98 Ultimate Match - 75
ACA NEOGEO FATAL FURY 2 - 53
ACA NEOGEO FATAL FURY - 51

X360
Gears of War 2 - 84
Sonic Unleashed - 70

PC
Final Fantasy VI - 97
Metal Slug XX - 93
Borderlands GOTY Enhanced - 89
Assassin's Creed IV Black Flag - 85
Assassin's Creed Freedom Cry - 77

Tomb Raider 1-3 Remastered - 10/10
Ring Fit Adventure - 10/10
Princess Peach Showtime - 8/10
Broken Sword Reforged - 9/10

That's all until now. I don't have too much time to play games. :(

I'm pretty optmistic that I can clear Echoes of Wisdom before the year ends though!

Only games I played in 2024 and rolled Credits. Rolling credits essentially means I liked the games, because if I did not I would not finish it LoL.

Pikmin4 10/10
LoZ Echoes of Wisdom 9/10
Paper Mario Thousand Year Door 9/10
Prince of Persia Lost Crown 8/10
Like a Dragon Infinite Wealth 8/10
Unicorn Overlord 7/10
Animal Well 7/10