archbrix said: My take on NSMBU is that it should have been a Wii game. The only change would have been 480p and it would have been a great swan song and sold a ton on that console. I think a lot of the criticism comes from people just being tired of the "New" games by then. Some were better than others, but none of them had the charm of the originals (minus Lost Levels). NSMBU is a good game and I did really like the overworld, but the squirrel power-up was pretty lame and I do have to agree with @curl about the visuals for a WiiU game; playing Tropical Freeze after Mario was a night and day difference. |
Not aimed at you or anyone in particular but I think people were always going to complain about NSMBU regardless of what they brought out because even the game you mentioned in comparison Tropical Freeze received just as much backlash despite being one of the best 2D platformers made. Both these games released in a period when people were wanting a new Prime or Galaxy and the annoyance of not getting them stuck with the games ever since, the two games themselves as Kakadu also highlight with the former are not bad games and better than what people would have you think.
2D games in general have a strange stigma attached them where some people will think they're not worth much no matter how good they are and we've seen this even in today's era when Metroid Dread was revealed, despite people being more open to 2D games today compared to back then and Dread being one of the best games of the year the are still those disregarding its merits because it is a 2D game.