The_Liquid_Laser said:
Jaicee said:
So you've never heard of Mothra vs. Godzilla before? Or any of the Mothra movies? You know, the island fairies who serve as Mothra's twin priestesses? ...And you call yourself a fan!
(Not that I don't enjoy the short before Godzilla 1985 you highlighted mind you. )
|
Heh, I really don't call myself a fan. More like a bored person who watches hoping they will be somewhat entertained.
|
I see.
Personally, I rank Godzilla films in four tiers.
Tier 1: Top-tier Godzilla films are meaningful and relevant entries that do much more than just entertain. They capture a sense of the Japanese psyche and the traumas and struggles of its people at various points in their history using kaiju as powerful metaphors. They're genuine art films. This tier includes three films, each from a different generation of Godzilla movies: the original Gojira (1954), Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah (1991), and Shin Godzilla (2016). These are the real masterpieces. These aren't just good Godzilla movies -- movies that are good by the standards of this particular franchise -- they're good movies, period.
Tier 2: Second-tier Godzilla movies are entries that aspire to tier 1 art film status, but fall a bit short of being true masterpieces. Examples of films I classify as tier 2 include Mothra vs. Godzilla, The Return of Godzilla, Godzilla (2014), Godzilla vs. Hedorah, Terror of Mechagodzilla, and some others. These are still issue-driven, evocative movies, but maybe rely on contrivance too much or lean equally on pure entertainment value in a way that can distract and lift some weight from the core narrative.
Tier 3: Third-tier Godzilla movies for me are entries that exist purely to entertain. This describes the majority of Godzilla films really, including Godzilla vs. Kong, most entries in the Champion series of Godzilla movies, and many others. These movies do not constitute serious art, but are often (including in the case of Godzilla vs. Kong) genuinely fun to watch. My first Godzilla movie, Godzilla vs. Megalon, qualified in this category. I was appropriately seven years old at the time, so really the ideal age for that movie. I remember how I used to watch it back then: I thought the human interactions in the movie were dumb and boring, so I'd typically fast-forward through them to get to the monster scenes, whereupon me and my best friend at the time Casey would play-act as various monsters on-screen, pretending to control them like it was a video game. Typically, I'd assume the role of Godzilla and physically act out his parts and Casey would assume the role typically of Jet Jaguar and act out his. It was fun. The difference between this and a tier 2 movie of the same era like Terror of Mechagodzilla for example is that I would rarely fast-forward through the human interactions in the likes of Terror of Mechagodzilla because, even at the relatively young age of 11 when I first saw the latter, I wasn't bored by them. I wanted to see the whole movie, not just the monster scenes.
Tier 4: These are the genuinely bad Godzilla movies I don't enjoy watching. Mostly this category consists of films that seriously pretend to be weighty art movies but don't actually have anything to say and resultantly are highly pretentious and annoying. Godzilla Raids Again, Godzilla (1998), and Godzilla: King of the Monsters (2019) are examples of tier 4 Godzilla movies in my book. The worst of the worst, not worthy of your time.
Last edited by Jaicee - on 10 April 2021