64 for me. Simple yet revolutionary for its time

I think what made Odyssey especially sweet to me was that it felt like exactly what was missing with 3D World; that sense of adventure, of interesting worlds to explore, of ambition and scope and Mario doing exciting new things instead of playing it safe.

Welp, Odyssey is my favorite 3D Mario of all time(then Sunshine, i loved sand bird), I'm genuinely satisfied and pleased with charming gameplay variation.

3d world then galaxy

Galaxy would have to be the best Mario game ever made, however since i played Mario 64 first, its WoW factor of 3D worlds at the time was unrivaled so due to nostalgic reasons, i pip Mario 64 just over the Galaxy series.

Odyssey, imo the best platformer I’ve played period.

It seems that the galaxy games are the most popular here by a pretty large margin. I thought the votes being split between both might hurt them individually, looks like nintendo should get working on galaxy 3

I think if you rate them at the time of their release it'd be something like:
64 > Galaxy > Odyssey > Galaxy 2 > Sunshine

But rating them now, with 64 obviously being dated (but still amazing), and Galaxy 2 definitely being better than Galaxy even though Galaxy was more of a surprise since Galaxy 2 just refined and improved on the Galaxy formula, I'd say, ignoring nostalgia:

Galaxy 2 > Odyssey > Galaxy > 64 > Sunshine

Never played 3D World but it just looks less interesting than any of the others.

The next 3D Mario game should be on Switch and should be Galactic Odyssey, that melds Odyssey and Galaxy together, with Cappy and a variety of tiny planetoids with larger ones making up levels. Then they can put these two great Mario concepts to bed and bring something new next gen.

I'd say Galaxy 2 > 64 > 3D World > Galaxy > Odyssey >>> Sunshine.

I remember getting bored with Sunshine but I'm looking forward to giving it another shot with the 3D Collection. I'd score every non Sunshine game 95+.

Damn straight, not only would it be a guaranteed 20 million plus seller on Switch, but I'd sell them my damn soul for Galaxy 3 haha