It would probably be the same experiance, but the graphics would be worse.
You can see the lightning/shadows, and reflections are "new gen" worthy compaired to the PS4 version.
The textures on the suit look better too.

Is it just a better looking game than the PS4 version? yes.
Could it have run on the PS4 (and just looked worse)? yes.

But isnt this what new gens are? You get better looking games.
Very rarely is there stuff thats only possible (gameplay wise) via new hardware.

Mainly new gens are about getting bigger and better looking games.

Theres probably people that would argue, Halo 5, would be possible as a Xb360 game, just graphics cut back some.
Same as theres people that will claim gameplay wise, call of duty on the PS2, isnt drastically differnt in terms of gameplay on the PS4/Xb1.
What you cant argue, is that graphics havnt changed since.

He always preaches about experiences only possible on next gen and as pretty as the game looks by his own criteria it doesn’t fit his description.

He’s already shifted the goal posts for this in response to what Sony or MS have done. Remember, Xbox needs to blow us away with experiences entirely not possible on last gen consoles. But HorizonFW is great because there was a non-gameplay trailer that showed you going underwater. Have you ever played a game that allowed you to go under water? I didn’t think so.

He’s already shifted the goal posts for this in response to what Sony or MS have done. Remember, Xbox needs to blow us away with experiences entirely not possible on last gen consoles. But HorizonFW is great because there was a non-gameplay trailer that showed you going underwater. Have you ever played a game that allowed you to go under water? I didn’t think so.

He always preaches about experiences only possible on next gen and as pretty as the game looks by his own criteria it doesn’t fit his description.

Lets see how close it gets then, to the trailer, when it releases.
Supposedly it was all ingame, captured on a PS5.

I suspect actual gameplay will look much like that trailer though.

Lack of talent, tell that to Playground and Obsidian. The other studios don’t have near perfect records like those but are still capable of making great games. I mean cmon we getting a Xbox exclusive Skyrim. I don’t need to see gameplay to know Obsidian has that in the bag. 

I mean they made it clear they are doing both small to large scale games. Guess that’s the next stigma to overcome. But I wouldn’t say they are lacking quality. Aside from Bleeding Edge games like Ori 2, Gears Tactics, and Minecraft Dungeons got good scores. This month has 4 XGS games and I don’t expect all of them to be critical duds either.

Maybe Battletoads, but Flight SIM and Wasteland 3 each have a ton of care put into them if you keep track. Tell Me Why strikes me as a wild card. 

i would be amazed if gameplay is on similar level of what we saw on Horizon: Forbidden West. Truly, this would be true next gen on my book.