I'm calling the race for Biden. It's clear to me at this point that that's what's going to happen. I'm not sure what'll happen in the general election, but I'm pretty sure about how the Democratic primary contest will shake out.
Specifically, this is going to wind up as a contest between Joe Biden (representing the neoliberal and conservative factions) and Bernie Sanders (representing the progressives). There was a brief moment after the first debate round wherein that shape of the race appeared to be changing, but it keeps snapping back to this specific form.
To illustrate what I mean, let's compare the Real Clear Politics polling average of the top four best-polling candidates just before the first round of debates in June and the RCP polling averages of those same candidates now, immediately after the second round of debates in late July:
Before Any Debates
Biden: 32.1%
Sanders: 16.6%
Warren: 12.4%
Harris: 7%
Now
Biden: 32.2%
Sanders: 16.5%
Warren: 14%
Harris: 10.3%
As you can see, in the long run there's basically been no movement. As you can also see, the recent round of debates (at least according to the two post-debate polls that are now out) had no impact for either Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders, Cory Booker, Andrew Yang, or Tulsi Gabbard, the ostensible winners according to the press, and neither did it cost Biden any support. (Biden was also averaging exactly 32.2% just before this latest round of debates, so his average doesn't appear to have changed at all as a result so far.)
What's more, the debates will mean progressively less going forward, as viewership invariably declines with each successive debate. The first one is the one that always matters the most by far. If that didn't change the contours of the race fundamentally (and, as we can see, it didn't), then probably nothing can.
NOW, let's add up the votes of the factions to see which one will likely emerge victorious:
Liberals (Biden + Harris) = 42.5%
Progressives (Sanders + Warren) = 30.5%
That's pretty much the same as Hillary Clinton's 12 to 14% overall margin of victory over Bernie Sanders in the 2016 Democratic nominating contest.
@DarthMetalliCube spoke of generational differences, and I'd like to remark on that as it pertains to this contest. What we see overall is that older people writ large (Democratic-oriented voters over 65, I mean) and younger people writ large (Democratic-oriented voters under 30, and more especially under 25) have made up their minds: older voters are determined to support Joe Biden and younger voters are determined to support Bernie Sanders. My generation, Generation X as we're known, in contrast, is proving, as has been assessed of us throughout our lives, comparatively disloyal hard-sells; the least doggedly tied to one candidate, and not generally aligned with either Biden or Sanders.
I think it's worth pointing out here, in this connection, that my generation, and especially the women, has also been the principal anti-Trump resistance movement demographic; the people most likely to attend most of those major protests that you've seen frequently since Trump took office. They've done surveys and analysis of the demography of these demonstrators and found their median age to be 49 and that about 70% of participants are female (whereas the Democratic Party, in comparison, is 59% female, so even relative to Democratic Party membership, the resistance movement has been a predominantly female phenomenon). The plurality of those voters prefer either Elizabeth Warren or Kamala Harris (myself included). My point is that, if the contest winds up being between Biden and Sanders, like it's almost certain to be, then to be honest I fear that that might be a bit of a turn-off for some people (especially women) of my generation (including me), who, I remind everyone, are factually the leaders of the anti-Trump resistance; the people most passionately opposed to this president and what he stands for. I worry about this becoming a dispiriting contest for Gen Xers who want a fresher candidate, and preferably a woman. People don't often talk about my generation in connection to elections because it's a smaller one, but...I'm just saying that it might not be a wise idea to flatly ignore what we want, considering that we're the (albeit unacknowledged) ideological vanguard opposing the current president and his agenda; the main source of that energy.
Last edited by Jaicee - on 04 August 2019