To me the only disappointing thing was that they are still doing 3DS exclusive stuff

9/10 for me. They started strong with Luigi's Mansion 3, and ended strong with an Animal Crossing Switch announcement. A lot of games were shown, and the pacing was great. Two big first party titles revealed, and a bunch of great first and third party announcements throughout.

Highlights for me include: Luigi's Mansion 3 (i'm most hyped for this one!), Animal Crossing, Final Fantasy 7 (which i've never played, but always wanted to), Katamari remaster, Star Fox in Starlink, Cities Skylines and Civ 6. Yoshi's Crafted World looks so much better now than it did at E3 last year, imo. All in all, great Direct.

Only reason why it's not a 10 is because Nintendo Switch Online is disappointing. No SNES games, didn't reveal the special offers, and didn't address the cloud save concerns. Also, no Animal Crossing Switch trailer or gameplay.

9/10 Only the online section let it down but other than that not much to complain about.

Negative infinity because no Pikmin 4.

6/10 for me. If I was basing my score on games alone, this would've been an easy 9. Maybe a 10. But I just can't excuse how badly they botched the online.

Really great direct, 9/10 for me. I'm baffled how they keep announcing games without showing much of em when we have already SO MUCH games teased for 2019 already. Like damn.

We got dates and a final look at this year which is looking really great.

Mainly we have :
-Super Mario Party - Oct. 5
-Diablo III : EC - Nov. 2
-Pokemon Let's go - Nov. 17
-Warframe - Nov. 20
-Smash - Dec. 7
-NSMBU - Jan. 11
-Yoshi - Spring 2019
-Fire Emblem - Spring 2019

So far we don't seem to have big droughts. I said after 2018, i don't see Switch having big droughts anymore and this is really confirming it.
And some other smaller stuff. I think it's a pretty great line up so far

I have to sleep on it, but overall, considering everything, a rather good direct at face value.

9/10

So much awesome in this direct! I actually want to give it a 10, but it looses points for the online portion, and I would have also enjoyed it more spoiler free. In spite of these negatives, the rest was so awesome that it brings the score up to a 9. Just so much content. Wow!

9/10
Great Overall! Sucked that stuff got leaked but they made the right decision to delay it.

Well it's not getting 8 that's for sure.

Otherwise it was ok, personally I'd give it a 6.