I think I will wait to see both of those games at E3 to decide. But from what I've seen yet I think Days Gone will score in high 70s and Crackdown in low 70s with possibility to drop below 70. But considering they've spent 20 months for rework it is hard to say.

Neither seem among either publisher's best releases to me, but Crackdown feels like a 70s release while Days Gone could be in the 80s.

Fable Legends seemed practically ready to release when it was cancelled.

Days Gone easily. Crackdown 3’s delay bodes very badly for the game. There’s clearly several issues there that were not aware of. I’m thinking it’ll score in the low 70’s, whereas Days Gone will be mid to high 80’s once the game is poilished.

Days gone, but not by much.
Days gone 80~83.
Crack Down 78~81. ( the 20 extra months will show results, a 60 game will become a 80 game... I hope).

Days Gone but I bet that Crackdown is more fundamentally fun, if not as polished.

I think Days Gone will score better score wise. But i think Crackdown will surprise peoplw with its sales. Both Sea of Thieves and SOD2 did uite well saleswise (yes i know those figures included trial versions) and i think CD3, which will rate higher than both, will sell very well.

In fact even thoigh i put DG to have greater sales, i wouldn't be surprised to see CD3 match it.

Both seem mediocre to me. Hope they both bomb.

LOL idk about bombing since people’s jobs are probably affected by that, but I agree both have looked pretty mediocre at times. I’ll vote CD3 since it has MP and the platforming action, Days Gone just looks like another narrative game to me and what they’ve shown of gameplay looked pretty iffy to me. A complete opposite of the reveal that was set in one of the horde areas full of action.

Probably Days Gone. It looks like an ideal zombie game. Crackdown 2 didn't score that well.

Days Gone will most likely win in metacritic. I don't even see myself playing Crackdown 3 even with my gamepass subscription, I don't care for arcade shooters, and I tried Crackdown 2 for free and the game just made no sense.
I really wish Microsoft didn't invest so much into this game, It's not going to sell enough to make a profit, and the studio could of made something else people would be excited for on Xbox.
The only game doesn't even show the true power of the Scorpio. We got Horizon 4, and soon to be Halo or Gears (Spinoff Gears) to show off the power of the beast. Crackdown should still release, but they just shouldn't have bothered touching the franchise again in the first place.
Soon to be a 9 year wait, and the previous games not even hitting 2 million is just a recipe for financial disaster. Gamepass has to come in clutch for this title.