I just tried it out for about an hour and a half, and I have to say, I hate it. or maybe thats an exaggeration. so lets say - I played it long enough to realize I do no not want to drop $60 on this game later this month. There were so many moments where I felt aggravated and frustrated due to the game's cluttered controls and fundamentally broken characters. i dont even know where to start in expressing my dislike for the game, but goddamn somebody needs to say it and im sure as hell gonna try.
the controls were way more intricate than they needed to be. the left stick for example is primarily used for moving around the tennis court. you then press A, or hold A, or double tap A to hit the ball, and in the half-second between pressing A and seeing your character hit the ball, you need to let go of the left stick and then position it again in order to actually aim the tennis ball. also depending on how long you held down A, your energy meter would increase allowing you to pull off trick shots (which i did not see one person online execute correctly), zone shots, or slow down time. BUT zone shots and slowing down time are both controlled by R. for zone shot you press R and for slow downs you hold R, and my god how did that make it past the beta? so many times i would find myself pressing R for just long enough to slow down time when i meant to do a zone shot, costing me the point. it got to a point where i just avoided trying to do zone shots entirely out of fear of holding it for too long. for god sake, would it have been so bad to map one to R and the other to ZR?
the characters are broken. for starters, you have Bowser, a character so big that his attack range covers half the court. not only that but his charged swings have enough power to knock your player a good way back down the court, with seemingly no way to recover. i was playing as Yoshi, who is marked as a "speed" character despite being no faster than any other character in any way. and then i really noticed no differences between any of the other characters, it was mainly just "well, i havent unlocked this character yet, guess that means im getting my ass handed to me"
and to top it off, the connection was terrible. Im talking SSB levels of input lag. this game is so fast paced and requires split second thinking. any lag at all would be a problem and this game has a lot of it. there were times where the game froze for over a second, and even more times where the opponent would hit the ball and it would bounce past my character before the game even recognized i was trying to use the left stick to move. and i could tell several of my opponents were having the same issue. i think i owe half of my wins to just serving the ball as fast as i could, hoping that the input lag would be too much to allow them to even hit the ball. and this game is heavily pushing for online tournaments with this game. this amount of lag is unacceptable.
heres just a list of some other minor annoyances
-the animation for Strike Shots (i think thats the name) just feels unnecessary
-i cant even keep track of all the similar names for each individual shot
-i had to play through the tutorial twice just to learn how to actually play the game
-a connection issue caused me to drop out of a tournament bracket
-the entire D-pad goes unused for some reason
-matchmaking was terrible and i frequently got paired with people who had considerably more point than i did