Sony, CoD and RDR2, with or without marketing deal.

Sony Obliviously! A possible $49 price cut and many games and bundles to choose from.

Yeah,hard to answer that when we don't know their holiday lineup yet. My vote so far is going to Switch. With Smash Bros and if Nintendo manage to release Pokemon this year it will be freaking huge.

i understand. The PlayStation 4 (Sony) this year AND holidays, because: God of War, Spiderman, Red Dead Redemption 2, the new Call of Duty (and Battlefield?!), Ni No Kuni 2, Dragon Quest XI, Kingdom Hearts 3, Detroit Become Human and many other interesting titles. All big games for fans of the genre and many newcomers will buy a PS4 then, i think.

Especially Nintendo who seem to be keeping a lot of plans close to the chest.

I think it will be competitive this year, but thinking right now Sony has a bit of an edge with its 2018 line up.

Well first what are we considering the Holidays? All of Q4 or just Nov+Dec?

And my current answer.........Sega :-}

Probably PS4 if they mark it down to 150-200 like they did last year. Can't beat cheap. But if Animal Crossing and Smash do indeed release this year and Nintendo does have ample stock, I'd give it to Nintendo. While COD does great software sales, at this point in PS4's life, it's not going to do a hell of a lot for hardware. Most of the audience who plays COD probably has a PS4 already. There's a lot of determining factors, but I'll hold my definite answer until after E3, think this one's gonna be interesting on all 3 platforms.

Sony will take it. They have the perfect third-party line-up. I don’t think Pokemon will be 2018 and I doubt Nintendo will win a holiday until 2019, although I’m rooting for them.

Too early to say, but Nintendo has a great chance:

- 2nd Switch holiday: there's a chance that, unlike previous year, Switch will have some kind of deal in November, which would boost it's performance in November. In December Nintendo is really strong.
- Sony has spread its games during all year. RDR2 is a very big title (and will probably be the biggest seller overall), but Nintendo could stack pretty big hitters (SSB, Pokémon?, Animal Crossing?) in Q3-4, which would offset RDR2 effect.

Of course it all depends on what games will be announced this E3.

Nintendo quite easily if I might add. Nintendo in general has stronger sales during the holidays, while Playstation sounds well over the year, their sales rarely spike the way like Nintendo systems can, especially in December.