I'm personally way more impressed by Shadow of the Colossus. BOTW does not look bad by any standards but Shadow is in a league of its own in this department.

Graphically, SotC hands down. It has better graphical perks. If it comes down to which one looks prettier, that depends on the eye of the beholder. If we go down the technial road, SotC eviscerates BotW anyday.

If we are talking about graphical superiority then obviously its SoTC. But if talking artstyle then that comes down to personal preference.

Not gonna vote. You can't compare pseudo-realism to stylistic cell-shading. Apples and oranges.

One was made with Wii-U graphics and the other one is a remaster with PS4 graphics.... Apples and oranges..

I was about to add that to my comment too. The premise of this thread looks like its trying to bait a console war. I'm sure the OP knows which one is technically superior. If so it really seems childish.

Visuals are a part of graphics. Otherwise why is this even a thread? On pure graphics alone, why would a machine with the power of the Switch be compared to the second most powerful console ever?

One runs on hardware 4x quicker, though the fact that theres even a debate shows how good they managed to get Zelda looking running on such handicapped hardware

This is a ridiculous and totally asinine comparison and poll, in my not so humble opinion.  Does the OP, or anyone for that matter, honestly feel that the two games are actually that similar from a graphically technological standpoint that there is something to debate here?

If someone just had to bring up these two specific titles, a better question would perhaps be: If anyone has played both, which story/world/gameplay had you more immersed and/or did you enjoy more?  ...and explain why.

both are kinda equal in graphics department but zelda has more color.their art style are different.animation in both these games are top notch.sotc is 60 fps.also sotc is very unique kind of game just like tlg.but overall sotc is better graphically.