By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Geof Keighley's Best Conference E3 Poll? Microsoft wins!

NobleTeam360 said:
So glad I don't take what users here think to heart. Other big gamers (twitch streamers and YouTubers) did similar polls and MS won there as well.

#Xbox is the best box

I second this ;P



Around the Network
JRPGfan said:
NobleTeam360 said:

It proves a lot of people liked MS's conference.

I think Amazon is a better indicator of how effecting the E3's where.

 

Highest SKU of Xbox One S is #106, followed by the next being #255.

Not 1 sku of Xbox in the top100.


Also look at the games (pre-orders not out yet):

#2 Mario Oddessey (NiS)

#4 Arms (NiS)

#8 Mario + Rabbits (NiS)

#10 Metroid Prime 4 (NiS)

#11 Crash Bandicoot (ps4)

#12 Splatoon (NiS)

#22 Xenoblade 2 (NiS)

#30 Kirby (NiS)

#31 Uncharted - The lost legacy (ps4)

#32 Yoshi switch (NiS)

#37 Spiderman (ps4)

#47 Destiny 2 (ps4)

#54 Assasins Creed Origins (ps4)

#55 Call of Duty  WWII (ps4)

#59 Forza Motor Sport 7 (xb1)

#61 Monster Hunter World (ps4)

#65 FFXIV Stormblood (ps4)

#67 God of War (ps4)

#72 Dragon Ball FighterZ (ps4)

#74 WolfenStein II (ps4)

#80 Call of Duty WWII (xb1)

#81 The Evil Within II (ps4)

#82 Days Gone (ps4)

#92 Destiny II (xb1)

#97 Assasins Creed Origins (xb1)

 

You tell me, who won E3?

"It proves a lot of people liked MS's E3" I'm not sure how your response to that comment is relevant but ok.

Also, I think Nintendo won E3 and I think Amazon shows that, so thanks for that



JRPGfan said:
NobleTeam360 said:

It proves a lot of people liked MS's conference.

I think Amazon is a better indicator of how effecting the E3's where.

 

Highest SKU of Xbox One S is #106, followed by the next being #255.

Not 1 sku of Xbox in the top100.


Also look at the games (pre-orders not out yet):

#2 Mario Oddessey (NiS)

#4 Arms (NiS)

#8 Mario + Rabbits (NiS)

#10 Metroid Prime 4 (NiS)

#11 Crash Bandicoot (ps4)

#12 Splatoon (NiS)

#22 Xenoblade 2 (NiS)

#30 Kirby (NiS)

#31 Uncharted - The lost legacy (ps4)

#32 Yoshi switch (NiS)

#37 Spiderman (ps4)

#47 Destiny 2 (ps4)

#54 Assasins Creed Origins (ps4)

#55 Call of Duty  WWII (ps4)

#59 Forza Motor Sport 7 (xb1)

#61 Monster Hunter World (ps4)

#65 FFXIV Stormblood (ps4)

#67 God of War (ps4)

#72 Dragon Ball FighterZ (ps4)

#74 WolfenStein II (ps4)

#80 Call of Duty WWII (xb1)

#81 The Evil Within II (ps4)

#82 Days Gone (ps4)

#92 Destiny II (xb1)

#97 Assasins Creed Origins (xb1)

 

You tell me, who won E3?

When showing nothing but a logo gets you the 10th highest selling game.



NobleTeam360 said:
JRPGfan said:

I think Amazon is a better indicator of how effecting the E3's where.

 

Highest SKU of Xbox One S is #106, followed by the next being #255.

Not 1 sku of Xbox in the top100.


Also look at the games (pre-orders not out yet):

#2 Mario Oddessey (NiS)

#4 Arms (NiS)

#8 Mario + Rabbits (NiS)

#10 Metroid Prime 4 (NiS)

#11 Crash Bandicoot (ps4)

#12 Splatoon (NiS)

#22 Xenoblade 2 (NiS)

#30 Kirby (NiS)

#31 Uncharted - The lost legacy (ps4)

#32 Yoshi switch (NiS)

#37 Spiderman (ps4)

#47 Destiny 2 (ps4)

#54 Assasins Creed Origins (ps4)

#55 Call of Duty  WWII (ps4)

#59 Forza Motor Sport 7 (xb1)

#61 Monster Hunter World (ps4)

#65 FFXIV Stormblood (ps4)

#67 God of War (ps4)

#72 Dragon Ball FighterZ (ps4)

#74 WolfenStein II (ps4)

#80 Call of Duty WWII (xb1)

#81 The Evil Within II (ps4)

#82 Days Gone (ps4)

#92 Destiny II (xb1)

#97 Assasins Creed Origins (xb1)

 

You tell me, who won E3?

"It proves a lot of people liked MS's E3" I'm not sure how your response to that comment is relevant but ok.

Also, I think Nintendo won E3 and I think Amazon shows that, so thanks for that

How its relevant?

These games are mostly from E3, and your looking at what people are pre-ordering.

If Forza Motorsports 7 knocked it out the ballpark, it would be ranked higher than #59.

Meanwhile look at how many Nintendo Switch games are at the top.

This isnt a matter of install base either, the switch has less units out than the xbox one does.



S.T.A.G.E. said:

You should see YouTube. Everyone fell for Microsofts deception with their wording. There's only a couple of aaa exclusives coming to Microsoft this year. Even gamespot called Phil spencer out in it, he clarified it and admitted they need to work on heir first party.

They had a great showing of games but 90 percent of those games are coming to PlayStation and many were none the wiser.

Deception LOL

They had exclusive clearly listed for their actual exclusive games. And console launch exclusive for everything else. YouTube is a terrible reference for anything. You can find thousands of people in YouTube who believe Sandy Hook was a hoax or that the Earth is flat. In the end, who cares. There was nothing deceptive about calling something launch exclusive. It literally means exclusive for the games launch.

Is Nintendos spotlight technically a conference? Otherwise I don't see how the answer is anything but MS. 



Around the Network
Green098 said:
JRPGfan said:

#10 Metroid Prime 4 (NiS)

When showing nothing but a logo gets you the 10th highest selling game.

Nintendo guys be thirsty bishes.... Wii U gamedroughts left many with just sand in their mouths.

(basically what Im saying is its been a while since the last Metroid game (that wasnt federation force)).



RolStoppable said:
Teeqoz said:

I'm with you on all of the big three being sub-par. Nitnendo has gotten a lot of hoo-ha for showing Metroid Prime 4's title, and just saying that a Pokémon is in development (which isn't even a surprise).

I take it, you've missed all the Switch sales predictions. VGC consensus was 30-35m lifetime. Clearly, most people had no clue that Pokémon was going to come to Switch.

I just know that it has been super heavily rumoured (we even had the Pokemon Stars rumours, which, I'm not sure had an actual source, it was just a rather logical conclusion drawn from the fact that the Switch is a portable).

But I'll rephrase: I wasn't surprised at all by the fact that a mainline Pokemon is in development for the Switch. The only thing surprising about the announcement was that it was done in such a throwaway fashion as it was.



I'm surprised that it won to be honest, I was expecting Nintendo to come out on top of the poll.



Flilix said:

Does this guy post a lot of XBox related stuff? Because these polls have slightly different results:

http://www.thesixthaxis.com/2017/06/14/who-won-e3-2017/

https://www.kotaku.com.au/2017/06/who-won-e3-2017/

http://www.strawpoll.me/13181935/r

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=229428

No hes more of a Sony guy.

Also the amount of people voted in Geoff's poll is more than all those polls you showed combined.



JRPGfan said:
NobleTeam360 said:

"It proves a lot of people liked MS's E3" I'm not sure how your response to that comment is relevant but ok.

Also, I think Nintendo won E3 and I think Amazon shows that, so thanks for that

How its relevant?

These games are mostly from E3, and your looking at what people are pre-ordering.

If Forza Motorsports 7 knocked it out the ballpark, it would be ranked higher than #59.

Meanwhile look at how many Nintendo Switch games are at the top.

This isnt a matter of install base either, the switch has less units out than the xbox one does.

No, I'm saying how is your Amazon list relevant to me saying "a lot of people liked MS's E3", and yeah look at all those NS games. Glorious to look at. I feel like you're trying to force some kind of argument nobody was even having.