I'd give it a 7.5/10 personally

+All the already-announced Switch games had some new footage, and it was great
+New game reveals with some gameplay like Yoshi & Kirby
+Metroid Prime 4 announcement and logo
+Pokemon confirmed to be in development
+No delays on any software so far

-Was hoping to hear about Animal Crossing Switch
-No footage for Metroid or Pokemon
-Very vague release dates for many games
-No real "out of the box" games announced

That said, I did enjoy the Spotlight. Short & sweet, got the job done and then tied in nicely with the gameplay streams in Treehouse afterwards.

7.5

Great announcements but the majority were just that. Some trailers to back up all of them would have been great. By far the best of bunch when it came to conferences.

A solid 7/10 for me. Could have been more if they had something to show from Metroid 4 or Pokemon and integrated some of the trailers from Treehouse into the showcase (Metroid 2 3DS remake!)