GTA IV
Monster Hunter
Diablo
Zelda Ww and SS
Gears of War

Fallout 4 too

Tales of Zestiria. Beautiful game but the characters besides Sorey were all meh, the story was meh, the battle system was meh. Really wanted to love it. I was 50+ hours in, but just couldn't bring myself to beat it.

MGS series... tryed it several times and no luck. Its not my kind of game. Also Batman. Arkham city - have it for x360 and WiiU. I did my best. But this game just don't clicks with me.

I largely agree about the Crash series.  It was basically an inferior Donkey Kong Country where you run forward instead of right.  But what made the PS1 popular were the cinematic games like MGS and the great JRPGs like FF7 and Xenogears.  No one really questions that the N64 had far superior platformers.

Or FPS. Goldeneye and Perfect Dark really did set the bar for console FPS gaming untill Halo dropped, otherwise FPS gaming was strictly only viable on PC.

Monster Hunter - I played about 20h, even had a friend to play with. But after realising the whole game would consist of killing monsters repeatedly to get new armour / weapons, just to replace those with a new set of armour / weapons by killing a monster repeatedly... nope.

Uncharted 3- I liked Uncharted 2 and I'm totally into Uncharted 4. No idea what happened there.

Pokémon X / Y - I love Pokémon but I disliked the setting so much. The only Pokémon games I never finished.

Mass Effect 2 (PS3) - Really tried to like that one but it just felt like a chore to play for some reason.

Animal Crossing New Leaf - I think the premise of the game is awesome but for some reason I just stopped playing after a while and never came back even though I tried to get back into it.

GTA IV - Didn't like the city and didn't like the characters. GTA V is miles better in my opinion.

For me it would be almost all of recent Bethesda open world games, the most noticable would be Skyrim and Fallout 4.

To summarize my feelings: lacking or boring main story that gets completely lost behind all the other things to do, big worlds filled with a huge ammount of generic quests, coupled with repetitive gameplay.

I never finished these two games. Ill probably give Skyrim another try on the Nintendo Switch though.

GTA V.- cuz the game is so ambitious, unfortunately; open worlds arent for me.

Xenoblade.- cuz I love jrpg but this game feels like a mmorpg and I don't like those either.

Mario Galaxy.- cuz I love Mario's in general, but this one didn't do it for me.

Taless of berseria.- I skipped a few entries of the series cuz is getting extremely repetitive. When I heard about the dark tone of this game is decided to give it a shot and.... yeah, more of the same.

I may get some flack for this, but overwatch. I just recently bought it along with some other games and to be honest I played it for about two days, but it just does not seem like my type of game at all.