Come on guys, on what planet is 84 a low score?

Thats fine. Nintendo has had problems with HD development, so Im just asking you that if it gets 84 on MC, you will still call that a great score for the game? I would be disappointed, so I might need you to comfort me...

People are quickly to throw great things into the bin. Regardless of what was already there, the great thing doesn't stop being great, just terribly underappreciated by an unsatisfiable owner.

The planet of Final FantazeeEeeEEeEeEeee.

Even so, that's still a weird train logic to have. "This entirely different game in concept, gameplay and characters that got a port scored the same!". Even if they bear the same name, they're different games, so I don't see why the score of an updated FFX port should be of any reference. As I said, no Final Fantasy will ever beat FF IX's metacritic score of 96 (or 94, can't remember now), but that doesn't mean all FF games onwards fail for some reason just because they didn't grasp that score. That's not how it works, or at least how I perceive it shouldn't work at all.

Yep, Final Fantasy X and XV, though they share some similiarities, are not very similar. So I don't think that comparison is fair. What's more, metascores are totally irrelevant, the only thing that matters is your own personal taste. I've played highly acclaimed games which haven't enjoyed at all (Skyrim for example), and games with mixed reception like FFXIII-2 were pretty good. So I don't see why I should care at all xD.

I am surprised by people who love FFXIII, I am emotionally attached by some of the other FF's, I want Vivi and the mages to enjoy a long life, I felt so sorry for them and I don't had any moment where I felt the same for the characters of FFXIII.

Story wise it was complicated just like other FF games like FFVII or FFVIII, but even the last one who is certainly not the most loved FF game had some great story moments, I loved the atmosphere of the school and the first mission and school fight pumped me up so much. (makes me remember that I hoped FF type 0 would be same and another SE game that ends up worse than FFXV...ugh I even platinumed the game how fast did I forget the game X_X).

but worst of all, I am honestly shocked that people love FFXIII music... I can listen to the albums of FF games and love them but can't with FFXIII..

With FFXIII I even went so far to read a 10 pages script about how to love FFXIII and I still din't after reading it...   The only postive thing I can say about FFXIII is that it had a sequel. With FFXIII I had to force myself trough it while FFXIII-2 was a game where I had moments where I was looking forward to going home and play it and see what happens if i go back trough time portals).

Different standards for different type of games and platforms, I see no use in this comparison honestly

84 eh. Thats aligned with xcx. Oh well, not that it matters since unless the next reviews really hate it, its not gonna go below 80 and 84 is still a really good score

Like I said to that other user, it just didn't fit your taste. Nothing wrong by it.