The difference between these numbers is 195k which is 24.44%

Very impressive numbers for the XB 1.

About 30-40k higher for the Xone than I expected, I wouldn't be too surprised if it took November as well, due to the number of deals available for it. I expect it, ps4 and 3ds to all have a good month, though. 

It's a bit disappointing how far off Amazon was as a predictor last month, however, really leaves us without a good sense of the market save for the NPD reports. 

I don't know. I wouldn't count PS4 out just yet.  I think Amazon is going to end up being accurate this month.  The problem with Oct is there was either lack of stock of the Gears Bundle or a glitch in counting it in the Top 100.  However, the other retailers showed a different picture, with the XBO doing better than the PS4.  Looking at the other retailers, now, shows a change in Nov. These are the Top 50 in video games overal, though I will only be looking at PS4 and XBO HW.

Gamestop: #12 - PS4 Pro, #26 - XBO Gears + Forza, #28 - PS4 COD, #29 - XBO Gears Ultimate Ed, #34 - XBO Gears + Rare Replay, #35 - PS4 Pro + PSVR

Walmart: #1 - PS4 COD, #4 - XBO Gears, #5 - XBO Minecraft, #6 - XBO BF1, #8 - XBO The Division, #9 - PS4 UC4, #12 - PS4 Pro, #31 - XBO BF1 SE, #38 - Gears SE, #40 - PS4 COD + GTA, #41 - XBO BF1 SE

Target: #6 - PS4 UC4, #7 - PS4 UC4, #9 - XBO Halo, #12 - XBO BF1, #17 - PS4 Pro

Best Buy - #1 - PS4 Pro, #5 PS4 UC4, #16 - XBO BF1, #17 XBO BF1, #29 - XBO Gears, #30 - XBO Minecraft, #41 XBO Madden

To me, the only one you can make a good case that the XBO leads in is Walmart, while the others it looks like the PS4 has a lead.

Numbers don't include digital sales so we don't know if it is not second including digital.

And before the discussion about digital sales picks up, from the NPD insider from GAF:

"Those digital shares are inching up now. The 30% number Mr. Jorgensen [EA's CFO] put out there still a good baseline, but we're now seeing titles come in even stronger digitally."

Mod Edit ~ CGI

Both Consoles are doing great, even 3DS, loving it.

All via Aquamarine (Astronaut Claire): https://twitter.com/AstronautClaire

• According to NPD, $375.8 million physical SW was sold in USA+Oct 2016 and $129.9 million digital SW was sold. Digital console SW rate: 25.7%
• According to NPD, $337.7 million physical SW was sold in USA+Oct 2015 and $47.1 million digital SW was sold. Last year's digital rate: 12.2%
• Every Nintendo title combined comprised a mere 5% of sales at NPD USA Retail in Oct 2016, and we're almost at the holidays. Down -43% YOY.
• Battlefield 1 alone sold more than 4 TIMES as much revenue as every Nintendo title combined
• Out of $376 mil SW at Oct 2016 NPD USA Retail, PS4 SW sold $171 mil (45%), Xbox One SW sold $156 mil (42%), and Wii U SW sold $13 mil (3%)
• At Oct 2016 NPD USA Retail, PS4 software is up +58% YOY, Xbox One software is up +22%, and Wii U software is -52%. All software is up +11%
• Looking at SW unit sales incl. bundle SW: PlayStation was up +40.1% YOY, Xbox was up +6.6%, and Wii was -40.8% at Oct 2016 NPD USA retail.
• Accessories decline from $160.2 mil to $121.0 mil (-24% YOY) at Oct 2016 NPD USA Retail imply that PS VR had a small initial retail shipment

Why PS4 software rose more ? i believe Halo released in last Oct that could be one reason XBOX one is seeing less increase as GOW cant match Halo numbers..

so we dont have PS4 hardware numbers yet?

Larger install base = multiplats will see a bigger spike in revenue.