Most of the time motion controls were just a tacked on gimmick that brought nothing to the games they were used in, so I have to say no. I never saw the appeal of Kinect (or Sony's motion controls for that matter).
One instance that I prefer the Wiimote + nunchuck over dual analog would be FPS. Pointing with Wiimote seemed almost as good as using a mouse for aiming. CoD controls on WaW and BO1 for the Wii were almost perfect in my opinion. Just took a little time to master but once you did it was far superior to dual analog. Sad part is that I didn't enjoy the controls for Goldeneye even though I believe they had a CoD setup under control options. Just didn't see to have the same feel as CoD games.