Oh wow and it's leading by a lot. 

I have mostly just seen some from the bigger sites/magazines and that's why I made that assumption, seems I was waaay off though.

Good for Bloodborne, its taken a while for the the game to soak in but after playing the dlc I can say this is the best game in the series and the goty.

Well they are though and it is no secret if you follow their shows =p.  They other platform fans basically went to other sites/other projects :).

But... the OP has the nominees listed in them... o: And also, their site is rather crappy atm. I can't really watch any of their shows. I watch them on youtube, but for some reason they didn't post of their awards ones : X

Mario Maker is a revolution in world building games? Come on now.

Loved Bloodborne. Never played a souls game before and I rarely give big games a full second playthrough. Not only did I best this game twice, but I got the Platinum for it.

It's like Tim Burton made a baby with a souls game with Zaitochi being the godfather. Well deserved although I would be happy with W3 or BB winning.

Deserved!!!

I know but it isn't a multiplatform site like it was before, and I am fine with it only miss the days that they had discussions about more than Ps related.  I think only Kyle Bossman is the Nintendo fan on this site and he with Brad are the only Wiiu owners, with Elysse who was more of a multiplatform girl and  Michael Damiani who was also interesting because he also played niche games were great contributors.  People like Ian Hinck are fun but also are boring for discussions, he basically is the guy who said the last of us was alright but nothing compared to Bloodborne and I bet Dark souls III will be his game for 2016 =p.

Months ago, I said something like "If MGSV wins GotY from any respected sites, I'd bite myself on the ass" of something like that.

My ass is still safe.

Well deserved Bloodborne !