And Gametrailers GOTY is... *drum roll*

[brute]

Machina said:

brute said:
Bloodborne will probably win most of them and probably deserves them, but hopefully MGS5 can win some as well.

The Witcher III has won the most. Bloodborne has fourth most, behind Witcher III, Fallout 4, and Phantom Pain.

http://gotypicks.blogspot.co.uk/

Oh wow and it's leading by a lot. 

I have mostly just seen some from the bigger sites/magazines and that's why I made that assumption, seems I was waaay off though.