To me none of that screams day one, or a must have; for others perhaps yourself, it does. 

Guess people have different tastes, that led to different opinions. 

Idk, he's got a point.....mediocre admittedly might be a tad bit generous

Pretty sure I heard it was Free to Play, thus I quit paying attention to it.  So can't tell you much more.

this is about 2015.

Very unlikely there will be some epic must have game that Sony will announce that comes out this year.

If i've been paying attention at all in the last 5 years, video game companies like to introduce games super early.  Like minimum a year later release date from reveal.

So any game at E3 not on this list will be on the list with Uncharted 4 and whatever other big games are coming out 2016 or later.

Oh sorry, I'm thinking of wrong game.  Should have realized it since this is SONY games.  The one I'm thinking of is Ubisoft.  Deep Down i think?

That's the free to play one with teh cool CG dragon trailer way back when right?

Until Dawn and GOW3 for me this summer. Also, Shadow of the beast. BTW, does any of you knows when HellBlade will be released???

That's because it is more an port than a remaster or did I miss something? People are more tired of ports than remasters, we just saw the release of FFX/FFX-2 and the Arcania collection last week two ports, in two weeks ultimate SF4 port will release, in the summer we get a GOW 3 port (or remaster), Risen 3 port (again but this time with all DLC) and Journey port.... It is fine ofcourse because their will be people who enjoy it but I get that people are getting tired of them.

Based on the fact that I think the lineup is mediocre and it has few games that look interesting to me?  Do you want like a mathematical proof or something?

To give you an example, last year around this time we had an thread 'Sony 's 2014 holiday line up is amazing, can not believe people call it weak'

Project Beast/The Order/Driveclub/Littlebigplanet 3    4 Big huge Amazing AAA games.....

In retrospect half of those games did not release in 2014 and the 2 that did did not had great reception from gamers. In the case of Lbp 3 it is kind of sad how many already forgot the game. 

In Januari this year people were making list about how 2015 looks amazing....The Order/Bloodborne/Uncharted 4/R&C.....   in the end again half not released and one you may forget.

People who are excited because of lists always fool themself and some will fool themself again and again.  I hope not but the titles you mention have the possibility to get deleyad or simply being dissapointing. 

I remember 2007, and how we had a huge PS3 list of games that will/possible release in 08.  MGS4/Getaway Amsterdam/the next game from the Olympic team (ICO/Shadowcolusses guys)/FFXIII/Next Gran Turismo/Killzone 2/possible GOWIII etc...;    Except for MGS4 and some smaller titles nothing else released from the list :s

Greatness STILL awaits.... had to make that joke lol

but off the list, its not very good but from it, I'd get tearaway unfolded,rime,no mans sky