I own both XB1 & Wii U, but had enough time with PS4 to give a rating.

Upro & XB1 tied for best, DS4 is last by default.

The Upro is just perfect w/o even trying it seems, the controller is so light it melts in your hands. The look and feedback is great. & personally don't care for analog triggers so no pts docked. It is Ninty's best controller ever, and yes it crushes the GCN (with that lone, shitty z button that felt horrible when pressed)

XB1 is just very high quality, a nice evolution to the popular 360 controller.

DS4 is just ugly to me (those long ass handles), but I can't knock its functionality and it is at least better than DS3.

The dualshock is the gold standard for controllers and PS4 didn't mess with it too much.

The Wii U is a mixed, I like the pro controller, but not the pad.

Leave X1 third as feels odd in my hands.

WiiU, and Xbone controller looks to identical, so they both lose.

DS4 wins. And I'm not being biased.

fighting, racing, rpg, mmorpg etc. its perfect for all that.  BELIEVE IT!

I love my ps4, but xbox one has the better controller. Feels more comfortable to me, the touch pad is annoying most of the time and I don't really like the sticks at the bottom, toggled or at the top is better for me.

I really don't get all the praise DS4 got, I dislike that controller. I will say I do like it more than the ps3 controller, which I really hated.

The PS4 definitely has the best controller this gen...no contest in my opinion. Just like the 360 had the best controller of last gen.

I will say that the Pro Controller for the Wii U and the Xbox One controller are closely right behind the DS4.

Wii U pro is excellent. The X1 controller is second and the DS4 is 3rd.
The real number 1 is the gamepad though.

PS4>X1>Wii U
The PS4 is very well rounded controller, doesn't look as nice as the other 2 but hold and play just as nice yet does have more functionalities, like the touch pad, share button, the mic and the color changing light infront most of these I tought were useless untill I actually played on the PS4 and they are pretty nice features. The X1 is close second with a solid shooter/racer with impulse triggers controller but I feel the DS4 fits better in all the other genres. Never touched the Pro but it looked so bare bone It's not a surprising the battery life is so long.

I agree.

XBOX controller are amazing, bith XB360 and XBO but i prefer Wii U pro controller...

the sony move

walsufnir said: These threads “the one that came with the only system I own“, disturbed by people who actually have more than one console who can actually compare

Quoted for truth.  I wish more people could spend more time with their hated "competitor's" console.  A lot of eyes would be opened about a lot of things.