A good game is a good game and I'm sure critics won't give it a crap score just for the giggles. With the Order we all know it's heavily focused on storytelling, which is definitely not a bad thing, but the story better be damn good though. But if it's not too short, has solid, albeit not groundbreaking gameplay and can deliver on the storytelling then I'm sure it will get good reviews.

Your disregard of critics is way overdone and Eurogamer doesn't even score games anymore.

Why do you even care if you are already preset in your mind? 

Posts like this make any valid criticism look invalid, no matter what the score in the end is. Anyone who played a game should be able to criticize, whether you like it or not. 

If you buy anyway, why care?

You are spot on with your opinion about brand loyalty. This is the most sad part of it all but at least vgchartz is better than GAF. The mentality there is way more “be with us or against us“ with dozens of people to hunt down anyone who is skeptical of an exclusive to make memes about him, laughing at him and thus creating a place where you don't want to participate.

That said I really enjoyed Gears of War judgment while it got bad reviews

I am sure it will be a very good game and it is definitely very unique in its atmosphere and enemies but that wouldn't stop critics from giving it low scores because they have already made up their minds.

I don't, even if it turns out to be a decent game I'll gladly wait for it in the bargain bin.

Of course you will and I know why.

Believe it!

I am very convinced that it will get between a 78 and 85. Early reports coming in say that it is breathtakingly beautiful and has an excellent story.

Those two things alone should make up for any mediocre gameplay, and in fact the gameplay does have some unique aspects to it.

If you guessed becuase it doesn't have MP then you do know why, if not then I'm afraid you were wrong.  

See, I did know why