There were quite a few this past gen for me, starting with Brawl, then Halo Reach and 4, Battlefield 3 and 4 (but more so 3), Skyward Sword, A Link Between Worlds, and most recently Mario 3D World, Watchdogs, Destiny, and SSB U / 3DS in the current gen.

I really like the GTA series, but I have to say GTA IV. I didn't hate it, but I thought it was pretty average. I don't understand how that game is tied for the second highest meta in video game history.

Damn really glad I'm not alone on this GTA 4 thing.
#DownwithGTAIV xD

Mass Effect 1 and Red Dead Redemption were both massively flawed in my opinion. RDR is certainly not deserving of the praise it gets, and while ME1 isn't as praised as ME2 (for good reason), even the praise it does have is far too much (imo)

Super Mario Sunshine, Super Mario Galaxy 2, GTA series, Skyward Sword, Smash Bros Brawl, Resident Evil 2/4, Uncharted Series, Left 4 Dead series, Halo 4, TLOU, Halo Reach, Pokemon Gen 5

GTA IV... I found the game mechanics to be horrible as a whole... especially the driving and shooting controls. In addition, it just seemed to sap the "fun" factor that other GTA's have.

Uncharted 2

Though the game is really good I feel like the game didn't deserved to score a 96. IMO it should of scored between a 92 or 93.

Probably Zelda, since it's held in such high regard. I tried it on the N64 and didn't like it at all.

Skyrim.

GTA V started great but then i got actually bored and i really hated the handling of the air vehicles