Super Mario 64.

I don't despise the games, but I think Uncharted 1&2 and every GTA are overrated. Haven't played Uncharted 3

Super Mario 3D World for me. I didn't despise it, but I also didn't enjoy it nearly as much as previous 3D Mario titles. Mario games were always appealing to me thanks to the sense of exploration you got out of them, something which was sadly missing in the latest adventure...

Watch Dogs. It got much better reviews than it deserved.

Play with a friend it makes it 10000x better.

I don't dislike these games but I didn't enjoy the nowhere near as much as thought I would,
I actually dislike a lot, the gameplay in these.
Skyrim, GTA 4.
Honestly, particularly Skyrim has the shittiest gameplay I've seen i a game with 75+ metascore.
I wonder why it's only me that thinks so.
However, most other things in the game are really good and that's why It managed to keep me playing for over 90 hours.I would rate it 7/10

uncharted 2.

gta 4.

mass effect 2: way step back from 1, for me.

2nd runner up for me is no more heroes. I now it's not a high profile, heavy hitter, big seller, etc. But it felt just like my kind of game, being different, not mainstream, niche, new concept, a bit wack, gory, funny, etc. But overall the game just felt so... underwhelming. I guess I juts set my hopes too high.

1st runner up for me is Far Cry 3 which was a huge letdown cuz I like shooters. I heard so many good things about this one, and from what I've heard it really seamed like my kind of game, so I bought the PS3 version like a month ago. I bought it on the cheap thinking "if I like this I'll also buy Far Cry4" but so far I've played like 2 hours and got back to whatever I was playing before it. The game just didn't fel smooth at all, I can't stand playing it for too long, the smoothness in it just doesn't feal right. Maybe it's fps aren't that great, who knows? But having played 3D World, Mario Kart, SSBRos, CoD:Ghosts, Uncharted 1 & 2 this year alone which all play smooth and steady, Far Cry 3 just seamed off. Maybe I was spoiled by those other games and have to play less smoother games and then get back to Far Cry 3, I don't know, just felt kinda weird.

But the true winner for me is the Uncharted trilogy. Not that I think it's a bad game, cuz it isn't, but I think people overrate it so damn much. I've had the trilogy at home unplayed for years until early 2014 I finally started playing them. My idea was to go through all 3 games in a row. I started 1 and was actually having great fun to be honest, really great fun. But it just got boring too quickly. It was like walk to setting - shooting - cutscene, walk to the next setting - shooting - cutscene, walk to next setting - shooting - cutscene, etc etc. I stoped midway during U2 and just finished like 2 weeks ago. My 2nd biggest complaint about the game is its lenght. I finished the 1st one in less than 6 hours and 2 in less than 10, and I wasn't even speedruning, on the contrary, I was taking enough time to explore and see the settings (which in U2 are amazing). Uncharted lovers, don't get me wrong, but I really think that a game so small, even if it was perfection, could only go as much as an 8/9. And yes I know it has multiplayer but it ain't that great (although I've put a good 4-5 hours into it with my brother), and I know many disagree with me but I don't think it has much replay value in it. I don't replay that many games and most I do are usually gameplay centric or level-based games, not "cinematic expericence" games which I find to usually have much less replay value than other kinds of games.

Seriously? Loved that game... One of my favourites last gen!

What didn't you like about it?

I would suggest people explained why those games felt overrated to them like I did above and some have done before. But I see many don't do that and I feel it would be a great addition to the thread explaining why. Just don't get carried away when people don't feel the same way as you about some game. :D