Both look great in their own ways, though some need to bear in mind that visuals != graphical and technical superiority alone, so it's still mostly subjective. Same with artstyle. A game could have a great concept for an artsyle, but still be poorly executed graphically.

But I mostly wanted to comment on those poll results. Either it's displaying wrong for me, or it's the most evenly divided poll I've ever seen.

I agree with all that you say in your last post.

I'm all for graphics as my high end PC can prove, but I'm really getting tired of people only judging games by this one & only factor.

A game might not a graphical beast, but still be appealling because of animation, art direction & all over coherence in what it's presenting & trying to immerse the gamer in, take Journey for exemple or Katamari or Paper Mario.

Gamers are becoming such integrists, it's like some want to implement some sort of gaming Charia!!!

Enjoy the games & stopping bullying others because of different tastes!!! (not talking to you Rab, just in general).

Uncharted 4 looks more real, so that is where my vote goes.

Never said it was realistic, just comparatively more realistic, which (along with being less colorful) is what the losers in your pic all have in common.

Just taking a photo isn't very artistic, no, and neither is just making an imaginary world. I could draw a bunch of stick figures, say they live in the mystical Gorbenland, add a few unicorns and dragons and that would be an imaginary world, but it's no more art than if I took a photo of my cat making a funny face. Taking a good photo, just like making a unique and fleshed-out world, takes talent.

That way even an NES game can have better graphics than Star Citizen according to some people

You and all others like you love to disrespect the work of others. Do you think no skill is needed to be a good photographer ? And no imagination? Quite the uninformed opinion.

Also being draw don't automatically make something more imaginative or creative. But please carry on saying how efforteless is to make good photorealism graphics.

must be the reason why we have Oscar for better photography.

This is why I Love dogs and have you as one of my fave mods and Nintendo fan. You love ninty and appreciate their games but isn't oblivious to reality that altough zelda looks good and is strong on WiiU it doesn't compare with UC4 at least on this. Gameplay and history we will need more to judge and one of them will be a lot more subjective.

Uncharted 4 is clearly the best graphically. But honestly, I would like to see Zelda Wii U on decent hardware as it looks very reminiscent of SotC in terms of art style but clearly has low res textures etc. Liking the sun glow, very atmospheric.

its difficult to make direct comaprassion since the art styles are very different and also zelda has tremendous draw distance whjile uncharted is focus on short fields, but even if zelda had a shorter draw distance and used realistic graphics i doubt could match 1:1 uncharted 4, neverthless, even if graphics may play important part for the visulas, the art style also plays a very important part to make visuals attractive

a better comaprassion between uncharted 4 and a wii u game would be something like deus human revolution, shadow of the eternals, and so on

I did notice some downgrade in the uncharted game they showed in the gaming awards compared to what we sw at e3, but since the game is still on development i will wait and see if it ends up as they promised months ago

Whats wrong with that, if it's more beautiful then it has better Graphics