By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Persona Q Reviews! Metascore 87 [19 Reviews] Another GoTY Contender?

tbone51 on 20 November 2014
Ninsect said:
tbone51 said:
Ninsect said:
tbone51 said:
Dr.Henry_Killinger said:
Not even close.


Its actually tied for 5th  highest rated of the year


Not counting indies, ports and remasters...right?


Couting indies+PC games, not games that are ports/remasters, you mad?

Let's see...

If we go with your method it is:

1. Smash U

2. Shadowrun: Dragonfall

3. Dark Souls II

4. Shovel Knight

5. Kentucky Route Zero ACT III

6. Bayo 2

7. Diablo III: Ultimate Evil Edition

8. Velocity 2x

9. Dragon Age: I

10. Out of the park baseball 15

11. Child of Light

12. Mario Kart 8

13. TLoU: Left Behind

14. Persona Q 

Not even close to top 5. Tell me how you counted it

Srry i dont count dlc and games with a tiny amount of reviews as its BS



Around the Network
brendude13 on 20 November 2014

I still fail to see who this game is targeted towards.

Even with my love of P4G, I have no motivation to buy this game, especially since Etrian Odyssey gameplay doesn't seem like my kinda thing.

@ Wright

I don't think the studio who made Catherine have anything to do with this game. They are working on Persona 5 though.



tbone51 on 20 November 2014
brendude13 said:

I still fail to see who this game is targeted towards.

Even with my love of P4G, I have no motivation to buy this game, especially since Etrian Odyssey gameplay doesn't seem like my kinda thing.

@ Wright

I don't think the studio who made Catherine have anything to do with this game. They are working on Persona 5 though.


Yeah, EO isnt my cup of tea neither. Something that throws me off personally



HylianSwordsman on 20 November 2014
ktay95 said:
HylianSwordsman said:
Come on, there's only 11 reviews, just one really good score could pull it up even further!

Smash only has 15 on WiiU and we are praising the fuck out of it


Yeah but Smash will have 80+ reviews by the time all is said and done. Persona Q has time, but I don't think it'll get anywhere near that.



HylianSwordsman on 20 November 2014
brendude13 said:

I still fail to see who this game is targeted towards.

Even with my love of P4G, I have no motivation to buy this game, especially since Etrian Odyssey gameplay doesn't seem like my kinda thing.

@ Wright

I don't think the studio who made Catherine have anything to do with this game. They are working on Persona 5 though.


Mega Atlus fans probably. Kind of like how Hyrule Warriors sold half a million copies by targeting Warriors and Zelda fans, this game will get Persona and Etrian Odyssey fans. It'll be lucky to get half a million though, even on a userbase approaching 50 million.



Around the Network
outlawauron on 20 November 2014
noname2200 said:
Hardly a contender, but I game I look forward to nonetheless.

Just hope they don't over Persona my Etrian Odyssey!

You're right. Don't want to breath too much life in this stale genre.

You heard me.



"We'll toss the dice however they fall,
And snuggle the girls be they short or tall,
Then follow young Mat whenever he calls,
To dance with Jak o' the Shadows."

Check out MyAnimeList and my Game Collection. Owner of the 5 millionth post.

ktay95 on 20 November 2014
HylianSwordsman said:


Mega Atlus fans probably. Kind of like how Hyrule Warriors sold half a million copies by targeting Warriors and Zelda fans, this game will get Persona and Etrian Odyssey fans. It'll be lucky to get half a million though, even on a userbase approaching 50 million.

Except it only really targeted Zelda fans. Theirs like roughly 50k Musou fans tops on WiiU. Musou fans are all on PS consoles.



ktay95 on 20 November 2014
outlawauron said:
noname2200 said:
Hardly a contender, but I game I look forward to nonetheless.

Just hope they don't over Persona my Etrian Odyssey!

You're right. Don't want to breath too much life in this stale genre.

You heard me.

Even the remakes tried to make EO less EO =P



Ninsect on 20 November 2014
ktay95 said:
Ninsect said:

Director's cut: 92

http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/shadowrun-dragonfall---directors-cut

Still, Persona Q is not even close to top 5 with the conditions he imposed

Lol 4 critics, 3 of which never reviewed it in the first place and one that gave it a +5. So yeah 81 with 24 reviews seems much more credible.

Never reviewed it? Why does that matter?

We're including Smash with 15 reviews so there's obviously no limit on number of reviews, as long as the score is there. Still wouldn't matter.



The One and Only

VizionEck.com

Ninsect on 20 November 2014
tbone51 said:
Ninsect said:
tbone51 said:
Ninsect said:
tbone51 said:
Dr.Henry_Killinger said:
Not even close.


Its actually tied for 5th  highest rated of the year


Not counting indies, ports and remasters...right?


Couting indies+PC games, not games that are ports/remasters, you mad?

Let's see...

If we go with your method it is:

1. Smash U

2. Shadowrun: Dragonfall

3. Dark Souls II

4. Shovel Knight

5. Kentucky Route Zero ACT III

6. Bayo 2

7. Diablo III: Ultimate Evil Edition

8. Velocity 2x

9. Dragon Age: I

10. Out of the park baseball 15

11. Child of Light

12. Mario Kart 8

13. TLoU: Left Behind

14. Persona Q 

Not even close to top 5. Tell me how you counted it

Srry i dont count dlc and games with a tiny amount of reviews as its BS

Oh, so more conditions to fit your agenda. Okay, let's remove Left Behind and Shadowrun. That still puts Persona in 12th. How many reviews does a game need for your list? Persona Q only has 11 and Smash only 15. Is the cut-off 5 reviews?

I want to know how you counted it in 5th place.



The One and Only

VizionEck.com