Yeeeaaaaaah, i'm gona have to kill you.

Oh boy.

1. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Great game but not in the same level as Morrowind or Skyrim.)
2. Metroid: Other M (It's going to be the next Super Metroid they said...oh boy what a mess)
3. The Last of Us (It's good but iunno....)
4. GTA IV (Overall it was just pretty bland)
5. Killzone 2 (Great graphics but everything else just felt subpar)

- Metal Gear Solid 4 (a solid entry, but by far the worst of the 5 mainline MGS games)
- Killzone 2 (having played all the subsequent KZ games, I just don't get this one. The 'weight' and lack of colour completely ruins it)
- Super Smash Bros. Brawl (a massive step back from Melee in almost every conceivable way except roster)
- New Super Mario Bros Wii (completely shown up by DKCR, yet reviewed the same and sold millions more)
- Fable 3 (felt incredibly run-of-the-mill WRPG to me; Lionhead can do better)

I wouldn't say that game is overrated. In fact it is the most hated game of the Fable franchise :P (Yes, I dare to say even more than The Journey.)

Not counting the CoD games which would make all top five spots in this list.

1. Minecraft
2.  Assassin's Creed 2
3.  Ni No Kuni
4. God of War 3
5. Halo 3

1. Any CoD game
2. Last of Us
3. The Last Story
4. Super Mario Galaxy
5. Uncharted series.

It sold 5 million and got a pretty respectable Metascore.  That was the metric I was basing most of my list from (i.e. MGS4 gets a lot of flak on forums too, but you wouldn't tell it by the sales and reviews).

Fair enough!

5. GTA IV (It's good though. Just not 98/100 good)
Can't think of anymore...

1. Grand Theft Auto 4
2. Grand Theft Auto 5
3. Red Dead Redemption
4. Metal Gear Solid 4
5. Heavy Rain