Which is the better game in your opinion, and why?

Uncharted 3 in every way.

For me UC1 is better.

Uncharted 3 by miles

Except for shooting mechanics and AI

Enslaved

U3 was much better all the way around. If you have seen U1 lately? It looks unfinished and feels unfinished to me. Im glad I played it before the other 2 Uncharted games.

Uncharted 3. It still wasnt amazing with shooting mechanics but it had increased, the story telling was phenomenal, and the scale was much greater.

Personally i really liked all three but I feel they got better with each one because they progressed with the technology that they had available to them.

All three stories were great but I'd have to choose 2 or 3 from a story standpoint.

Gameplay id give to 2 because the shooting mechanics in the third one was a little messed up when they first released it.

i thought uncharted 3 was mindblowing, a great improvement over the first. loved the story and all the different environments.
there was more variety in uncharted 3.

I'm going to go ahead and say... Uncharted 3 obviously. But out of the 3 the second one was clearly the best.

I really enjoyed the series but after beating each game I didn't felt compelled to do a replay. Hard was too hard for me and I'm not a trophy whore. But good games anyway!

Uncharted 1 was really good and had some of the best landscapes in the series in my opinion. But it was too damn fucking hard... or maybe I just suck at those games