Hmmm
Maybe.

I want a sequel!!!

I never bought PASBR because it didn't have knockouts, that was the best part of Smash Bros. Why would you not copy that?

Less Smash.. More Power Stone.. Seriously they just had to copy Power Stone instead of Smash Brothers.. Would have served their Roster better with 3D gameplay.. And a name change.. Playstation All Stars Battle Royale.. Thats way too much.. Something like Playstation Battle! would be much easier for people to remember..

The characters in the game were fine. The game has massive balancing issues. Games with tier lists are fine, games where character x has no chance against characters y is what kills the game.

The balancing issues are so bad that instead of doing something to fix them, they made attacks completely worthless. Fat Princesses knight in the air was too good, so how did they fix it? They made it worthless. Drake's barrels aren't even worth using anymore. Raiden's down triangle in air went from no recovery to a few seconds recovery, etc.

I like the style of the game and how it was made, but they need a developer who's good at the genre to fix it and/or redesign the entire thing.

Superbot had no problem making Isaac and Kat  top tier.  Or maybe because they're garbage developers and don't know how to balance worth crap.

People will hate me for this but maybe they shouldnt rip off smash, maybe go to the MK/Street fighter type of fighter, or innovate and make there own.

btw you guys do realize there wont be a PS all stars 2 right?

When I first heard they were going to do a mash up fighting game I thought it was going to be more like this.....

Powerstone

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YiOu69Ypxac

or Urban Reign

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VptRF2QV7to

crossed with a bit of Evil Zone

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pU_u4z1JtYk

you should try it. the game is insanly fun. from my time with PS all stars and Smash bro's Wii i liked PS All stars more. i did however play it more than SSB

roster: i think it was fine but... i agree about crash and spyro and also about cole being only 1 character.

menu UI: god yes i agree.

franchise name: fuck yes, it's terrible.


what i would add?
i personally like the supers as a way to score but,.. most people seemed to hate that damage didn't create damage. if you want it to sell they'll probably have to change that.

at the very least,.. i think they should change the 3 levels of supers. i hated lvl 3 supers for breaking up gameplay with an stupid animation. i hated some characters for no other reason than their lvl 1 super sucked (sir daniel). I'd rather have 1 level of super with 3 choices: base super. super while holding forward. super while holding up. give me some choice in how i use that because sir daniel's lvl 1 super can't hit shit.