uncharted 2

Bioshock (all of them) and also Halo Reach and 4. Just off the top of my head those come to mind

Most Wii titles. The ones with Wii actually in the name i mean. Like Wii Fit and that kind of stuff.

Amen. I'm sure there are more overrated games, but of the games I've played, nothing comes close.

The game is a fundamental example of when everything functions, and nothing "works."

The. Last. of. Us.

And Sonic Colors.

For me, without a doubt, BioShock. Never understoor the supposedly "philosophical" side of the game, just saw a hugely improbable underwater city and awful FPS mechanics. This is the only prev-gen game that I simply could not play through due to being irritated by the game.

Another honourable mention for me is MGS on 3DS. I know this game is loved by everybody, and with good reason, but come on, those mega-length cut scenes and cheesy dialogue just got too much.

And that is it really. Almost every other game I played I thoroughly enjoyed, including some critical failures like Rage, NFS Hot Pursuit (3DS) and F1 (3DS). Overall, a really successfully gen for me.

Skyward Sword is totally overrated...  I found the motion controls so frustrating.

Red Dead Redemption
Grand Theft Auto 4
Grand Theft Auto 5
Metal Gear Solid 4
Heavy Rain
Oblivion
Skyrim
Smash Bros Brawl
God of War 3
Killzone 2

Never bought anything off ratings but off hype I was disappointed in GTA IV I still haven't finished it, it was just so uninteresting.

I don't have any comment to make really, but I think GTA IV is just as much as an exception as post-COD4 games for everyone that keeps saying it. That's pretty much unanimous.