By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Website Topics - VGC Rule: Why is the word Biased allowed but Fanboy isnt?

You are a f-ing moron.

Would that be allowed? No no no.

You're so silly

Would that be allowed? Yes yes yes.


It's all about the tone, not just the meaning.



Around the Network
ListerOfSmeg said:
JayWood2010 said:
binary solo said:
Everyone is biased. No one is truly neutral. Fanboy however is a particularly fanatical and one eyed sort of bias. So to call someone biases is merely stating a fact, though contextually it might be more or less accurate. Calling someone a fanboy is pretty much always insulting and flamebait.


Im going to use this as an example http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=5753523

In this post particularly he resorts into calling someone biased simply because he didnt believe the way he did.  Was it really called for?  Was there any reason to say that?  What did it establish?  And can he prove what he said?

Like the word fanboy, if you use it in the right context it is allowed.


I dont get what you are saying from that at all. I think you just dont like what he has to say and want him punished for not believing as you do.

You are acting just like he is, yet he only used the word bias to describe someone who either wasnt around or has selective memory.

You however just want to ban them so they cant post.

Seems you should be the one banned honestly as you dont even think any opinion that varies from your own should be allowed.

Really?  That conversation wasnt even with me and i never said if i agreed or disagreed with him.  But i see no reason for him to call someone biased for viewing things differently than him.

and if that was my motive i would want most of vgc to be gone xD lol




       

JoeTheBro said:
You are a f-ing moron.

Would that be allowed? No no no.

You're so silly

Would that be allowed? Yes yes yes.


It's all about the tone, not just the meaning.


Yeah :)  This I agree with 100%  

I dont care if someone uses the word biased in the right context but not to criticize someone for different beliefs is all.  That just escalates an argument most of the time.

As for the times you got banned i assume there is more to it than what you are leading on.  Ive never really paid much attention to your posts but yes ive seen bans that i dont agree with personally




       

I'm biased towards Xbox but I like PlayStation also. So if someone says I'm biased I'll just agree with them.



I'm not too familiar with the rules here. Are you allowed to refer to yourself as a fanboy?

If not, then historically I've just very, very, very much appreciated Nintendo's products at the expense of nearly every other company's.

Is that allowed? Or do you have to pretend that you have some sort of appreciation for things which, actually, you don't appreciate one bit?

Furthermore, if you are allowed to refer to yourself as a fanboy (which I am not sure you are allowed to do), then if you say, "I am a ___ fanboy" can others agree with you and say, "yes, certainly, you are a ___ fanboy"? Or is that still breaking the rule?



Around the Network
NolSinkler said:
I'm not too familiar with the rules here. Are you allowed to refer to yourself as a fanboy?

If not, then historically I've just very, very, very much appreciated Nintendo's products at the expense of nearly every other system.

Is that allowed? Or do you have to pretend that you have some sort of appreciation for things which, actually, you don't appreciate one bit?

Furthermore, if you are allowed to refer to yourself as a fanboy (which I am not sure you are allowed to do), then if you say, "I am a ___ fanboy" can others agree with you and say, "yes, certainly, you are a ___ fanboy"? Or is that still breaking the rule?


YOu are allowed to call yourself a fanboy.  Really most rules are just to keep things as respectul as possible which is why youre not allowed to call someone else a fanboy if it is meant to be a criticism upon that person you are accusing of being a fanboy.

If it isnt meant as a criticsm then it is ok.  This is why i see biased as no different.  Depends on how it is said.




       

NolSinkler said:

I'm not too familiar with the rules here. Are you allowed to refer to yourself as a fanboy?

If not, then historically I've just very, very, very much appreciated Nintendo's products at the expense of nearly every other company's.

Is that allowed? Or do you have to pretend that you have some sort of appreciation for things which, actually, you don't appreciate one bit?

Furthermore, if you are allowed to refer to yourself as a fanboy (which I am not sure you are allowed to do), then if you say, "I am a ___ fanboy" can others agree with you and say, "yes, certainly, you are a ___ fanboy"? Or is that still breaking the rule?

You're a fanboy.

It's a ok in this circumstance but it's safer to just never use it. I however live on the edge.



JayWood2010 said:
MDMAlliance said:
I imagine if you think about it hard enough, you'll realize that the reason why "biased" is allowed but "fanboy" isn't is because of connotation.

The word "bias" has a relatively neutral connotation. The word "fanboy" is quite negative and makes more assumptions than the word "bias" does.


Depends on how you say it which is why i said make a judgement call.  It is pretty obvious when somebody is using the word bias as a synonym to fanboy but because people can get away with it they do as you can with many rules right now.  

The truth is, people who want to get around the rule book can do so easily.  VGC creates a smarter version of a troll


Honestly, it still doesn't matter.  The whole point of not allowing the word "fanboy" is because the word itself is the problem.  People don't like being called fanboys.  While people don't like being called "biased" either, there really isn't a way to get the word "bias" to get the same reaction as "fanboy" unless it has become personal between the user and yourself.



JoeTheBro said:
NolSinkler said:

I'm not too familiar with the rules here. Are you allowed to refer to yourself as a fanboy?

If not, then historically I've just very, very, very much appreciated Nintendo's products at the expense of nearly every other company's.

Is that allowed? Or do you have to pretend that you have some sort of appreciation for things which, actually, you don't appreciate one bit?

Furthermore, if you are allowed to refer to yourself as a fanboy (which I am not sure you are allowed to do), then if you say, "I am a ___ fanboy" can others agree with you and say, "yes, certainly, you are a ___ fanboy"? Or is that still breaking the rule?

You're a fanboy.

It's a ok in this circumstance but it's safer to just never use it. I however live on the edge.

REPORTED.

Nah I'm just kidding.  I appreciate your sense of adventure.

OP: Probably people should refrain from throwing around buzzwords like "biased", "fanboy", "bigoted", etc. when having a formal argument.  Of course, having a proper argument is difficult and it's often much easier to simply insult the person you're arguing with.



NolSinkler said:
JoeTheBro said:
NolSinkler said:

I'm not too familiar with the rules here. Are you allowed to refer to yourself as a fanboy?

If not, then historically I've just very, very, very much appreciated Nintendo's products at the expense of nearly every other company's.

Is that allowed? Or do you have to pretend that you have some sort of appreciation for things which, actually, you don't appreciate one bit?

Furthermore, if you are allowed to refer to yourself as a fanboy (which I am not sure you are allowed to do), then if you say, "I am a ___ fanboy" can others agree with you and say, "yes, certainly, you are a ___ fanboy"? Or is that still breaking the rule?

You're a fanboy.

It's a ok in this circumstance but it's safer to just never use it. I however live on the edge.

REPORTED.

Nah I'm just kidding.  I appreciate your sense of adventure.

OP: Probably people should refrain from throwing around buzzwords like "biased", "fanboy", "bigoted", etc. when having a formal argument.  Of course, having a proper argument is difficult and it's often much easier to simply insult the person you're arguing with.


Honestly, the word "biased" IS the formal word to use.  "Bigoted," on the other hand, I can see as being one you can get banned for.  See, even if you use a neutral word with a negative tone, the thing is that you'll have to use words worse than "biased" to make the word "biased" itself become anywhere near the equivalent of "fanboy."