You are entitled to express your opinion and same goes for me also. You put some interesting points.

But in defense of my points I want to say "more" functionalities doesnt mean better. Six axis was an "added" option in dualshock 3 but looks at games like 'heavenly sword" or "lair". They had horrible controls.

I sold my PSOne, because the controller sucked compared to the N64 controller.
Fast forward to 2013 and the controller for the Playstation has not evolve much. The sticks are still badly placed, that is what kills it for me.

Once you played a FPS on the Xbox 360, there is no return.

The reason I prefer batteries instead of built in battery in controller is this. This is collecting dust for a long time. I just keep purchasing new controllers because I use them very roughly. Changing battery in dualshock 3 is a pain. Plus in that money I can get a new one.

x1 is better but ps4 remote is good as well

Wait... you're saying the sticks on the Dual Shock controllers are badly placed and mention your preference for the N64 contoller?

Tell that a PC gamer...

OT: Thread discussion is pretty pointless because about 95 % of the people hear have tried neither and are just trying to please their confirmation bias.

the DS always sucked for my hands and since the general shape didn't change it will still suck this gen... first my thumbs are natural human thumbs so their natural position is at a 20 degree angle position from the index finger not 40.... my palm meat is cramping up with DS sticks (I see you jiggling in the back).... then those D pad button being separated give me blisters if I play long sessions (couple hours).... and those sharp edge right side button the same (but less of an issue)... then you have the triggers, the DS3 one plain suck compared to the xb360 ones and even if they seem to have improved them XB1 seem to be even better than the 360 so I guess it will be a no contest again there....

so yeah pretty sure the only reason the DS4 gets any love is because it is a vastly improved version of the most famous pad now a day.... but pretty sure in a blind test with someone that has never been in gaming there is no contest.... the ergonomics of the XB1 pad is just more natural end of story..... the DS shape is more iconic...

competitive PC gamers.... the keyboard mouse combo is just deeper and more accurate.... but it is the less entertaining and confortable way to play IMO.... I have way more fun playing SP modes with a pad than a KB/M set up.... even on PC

DS controller was the one than was in need of more impoving. MS could have just released the 360 controller as it is and it would have been just fine. 

after this guy got caught lying about a ps3 purchase and his increadibly flat words of massive excitment over every MS product...

...i think he's just a MS marketing department employee paid to influcence social media.