By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Which Will Sell More Lifetime- GTA V (PS3 OR 360) Or Pokemon (X&Y)?

 

Which will sell more?

Pokemon! 59 34.10%
 
GTA! 94 54.34%
 
I don't care! 4 2.31%
 
See Results! 16 9.25%
 
Total:173

Using our numbers, I don't think how people can seriously say that it won't make 30m or less.
17.5m already FW.
Even with a near 90% drop it would still do 2m in week 2, about 1m in week 3, another few millions (2-3m) until Black Friday. Then Black Friday itself and the whole month of December.

MW3 broke 15m on 360 with a 1.4m lower first week during the busy time of the year.



Around the Network
pezus said:
Conegamer said:
Boutros said:
What is going on around here?


I don't know anymore... With regard to Pezus, I just see the 360 version having longer legs. That's all.

7.5m longer? Not going to happen

Sometimes I wonder what you're thinking >_>

Maybe, maybe not. Probably not, actually. But let's see!

Thggame will have the best legs in the UK and America so that'll ewerethebig sales el being tht coming years. 

Actually,have the numbers on the front page hanged? I thought heap between the was like nearly 2mil before! That's what Ibased my numbers on, anyway.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

pezus said:
Barozi said:
Using our numbers, I don't think how people can seriously say that it won't make 30m or less.
17.5m already FW.
Even with a near 90% drop it would still do 2m in week 2, about 1m in week 3, another few millions (2-3m) until Black Friday. Then Black Friday itself and the whole month of December.

MW3 broke 15m on 360 with a 1.4m lower first week during the busy time of the year.

And MW3 launched in November :o. 30m+ combined is very likely before the end of the year.

I'd say ~28m assuming there won't be adjustments.



Oh on one platform...then yeah it should.



Wow. I am getting to the point where using this site on iPad is so, so, so terribly bad that it really isn't worth it.

Apologies for the spelling errors. But you try using this site and see how hard it is,



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Around the Network
Boutros said:
Oh on one platform...then yeah it should.

Yeah, I'd like to change it but sadly it's simply not happening until I get back to my laptop right now.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Conegamer said:
brendude13 said:
If you mean GTAV on a single platform, then I think it'll be close, but Pokemon X/Y should just take it.

If you mean GTAV on both platforms, then...I'm speechless.

I realise I'm not overly cLear inthe OP, but I mean on one platform only. 

Good.

Conegamer said:

Maybe, maybe not. Probably not, actually. But let's see!

Thggame will have the best legs in the UK and America so that'll ewerethebig sales el being tht coming years. 

Actually,have the numbers on the front page hanged? I thought heap between the was like nearly 2mil before! That's what Ibased my numbers on, anyway.

Haven't sales always been more front loaded in the UK and USA? GTAIV on PS3 also had better legs. With the PS3 pulling away from the Xbox 360 in total sales numbers, I don't see how the 360 version can hang onto the lead for the rest of this year, let alone actually gain a 7.5 million lead in lifetime sales.



Your comparing Pokemon X an Y (two games which will sell almost identical) vs just one game on a single platform(PS3 or 360)?...that's not really a fair comparison...but any ways GTA V will probably end up with 19 million on PS3 and 17 million on the Xbox 360 LT. If pokemon ends up with 12-14 million I'd be quite impressed..but I have a feeling the 3DS is going to have similar legs as the DS and pokemon is launching near holiday season...therefore it should be 16 million at the max.



GTA wins hands down. I love Pokemon and will probably buy X (just cause X sounds cooler in any title) sometime with the special 3DS now that they confirmed I can have a Charizard again but GTA will get a pretty good hardware boost with only 5 or 6 million next gen consoles out there by the new year.




Get Your Portable ID!Lord of Ratchet and Clank

Duke of Playstation Plus

Warden of Platformers

GTA V



3DS Friend Code: 0533 - 6146 - 0418
PSN ID: atylerman5