Well, at least it didn't do terribly.

i dont think its quite like like, though it is similar. 

but based off this article it appears vgchartz has Gears of War: Judgment slightly over tracked, while based off of vgchartz track record of grossly undertracking the God of War series, by as many as 1 million at one point for God of War III, its safe to assume that God of War is either tracked right or is undertracked, but definitely not over tracked.

i tend to believe its undertracked, and wouldnt be surprised if its actually sold well over 1.5 million, just based off how poorly vgchartz has tracked GOW sales, and even with the real figures it wont update the sales. its undertracking the series by several million.

OP updated... Bulletstorm sold less than 1 million combined.

1.24M - at retail only. So, way overtracked.

MS seems to think differently

OT I dont think the world wanted another Gears, IMHO 4 entries in a series in one gen on one console is a bit overkill, and it was a prequel.

Bulletstorm, dont know what the hell happened their imagine how much worst it would have dont WITHOUT the Gears 3 beta

Also the release date didn't help. It released the same day as Killzone 3, so it was a no brainer which shooter PS3 owners would buy, and it shows in sales.

I don't think that's a valid argument. Maybe some people opted for Killzone 3 over Bulletstorm on PS3, but the modest sales and weak legs of Bulletstorm on all platforms shows there was little interest in Bulletstorm period.

I genuinely feel the bad multiplayer had something to do with the lack on interest in Bulletstorm. Split screen multiplayer would have helped sales.

Of course I'm basing everything upon VGC numbers, which are most probably flawed and overtracked.

But going by numbers, you really don't think Killzone 3 release impacted Bulletstorm sales on the PS3? The X360 version outsold it by well over 200%, of course usually shooters tend to do better on X360 but not by such a high margin. I think that's definitely a valid argument.

While I'm not at all disagreeing with you, of the top 10 Xbox360 games sold ever 5 of them have the name call of duty in their title. as well as those there are 5 more CoD games on the machine. Some games can get away with it, Gears just wasn't one of those games, I think everyone had cried out enough manly tears in Gears2/3

GOW Ascension is selling okay as i can see that game in Top 20 of UK mostly, so this is under tracked here.