I like this thread, its given me some few laughs.
Actually for me the internet connection thing is not the problem. Especially if you only need a short period of time for authentication. I live in a 3rd world country that has lousy internet that constantly pings out but MS did state its not a 24 hrs thing, which I hope remains to be the case but my issue is with paying extra for a game that has already payed for because I'm borrowing or lending is my main concern. This is the practice I do not want the industry to do just because they want extra cash from the 2nd hand market. The online pass to me was a better and a none intrusive choice.