I would say Uncharted 2 is the best console game of this generation.  It's almost a perfect game.  Although I hate on COD these days, I loved Modern Warfare 1 and this is a close 2nd.

Maybe some people prefer Demon Souls over Dark Souls.  Or Halo Reach over Halo 3.  Or Grand Theft Auto 4 over Red Dead (but any long time GTA players would agree that GT4 pales in comparison to GTA San Andreas)

There are probably some other choices I can put in the poll (like Borderland 2) but I can only put max of 10 choices for the poll.

Uncharted 2, nothing comes even close.

PS3 Uncharted
Xbox 360 Gears of War
Wii Mario Galaxy2

Flower.

Xenoblade, by far.

Demon Souls & Dark Souls

Just two of the handful or so games from this gen I would call classics and expect to still be playing years from now.

Catherine

red dead redemption

I agree with you on Uncharted 2,although i think it's overrated as hell!!! and i would pick Uc3 over it any day! but yes i agree.

Bioshock