By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - (Updated: GoW wins - Both bad) Sales - God of War Ascension vs Gears of War Judgement

Mr Puggsly said:
bevochan said:

Prediction:  Gran Turismo will surpass Halo Reach in lifetime sales this year.  And GT5 will sell more than Halo 4 lifetime (although Halo 4 still selling well)

More bundles of GT5 are coming?


ugh grow up



Around the Network
Mr Puggsly said:
bevochan said:

Prediction: Gran Turismo will surpass Halo Reach in lifetime sales this year. And GT5 will sell more than Halo 4 lifetime (although Halo 4 still selling well)

More bundles of GT5 are coming?

No bundle and the game didn't go below 15k per week this year yet... it is GT not a frontloaded franchise... legs is strong here. GT5



I think people are ,missing the fact that gearsj isn't mjust a prequel, but a spinoff. It did perfectly fine for what it is. Compared to gowa which was announced earlier, had more e3 coverage and had its own multi million dolla superbowl spot. Gowa is more of a flop compared to gearsj, and look at that massive 2nd week drop.



jaywood, i gotta ask, how in the hell do you manage to make every single thread you make, unintentionally a flame war?



CGI-Quality said:
J_Allard said:
Mr Puggsly said:
Heavenly_King said:
Considering Gears usually sells lots of millions week 1, I think from a prequel perspective, GOW:A is performing better.

Sony logic.

Selling less = performing better.

Judgement is not even made by the usual Gears guys.

As we've discussed before, this isn't entirely correct. Epic had a hand in the multiplayer portion. Besides, I doubt most buyers, in this case, would know who specifically developed what, making it a fairly moot point.

More importantly, neither of these two had particularly strong openings, but as prequels, you couldn't ask for/expect much more. 


Bulletstorm was great. It's not like People Can Fly are a bunch of amateurs. =P

 

I know it's not related to what you said, but hey, I wanted to say it.



Around the Network
nnodley said:
Mr Puggsly said:
bevochan said:

Prediction:  Gran Turismo will surpass Halo Reach in lifetime sales this year.  And GT5 will sell more than Halo 4 lifetime (although Halo 4 still selling well)

More bundles of GT5 are coming?

Here we go again with the bundle argument.


You can't escape from bundle arguments xD



CGI-Quality said:
J_Allard said:
Mr Puggsly said:
Heavenly_King said:
Considering Gears usually sells lots of millions week 1, I think from a prequel perspective, GOW:A is performing better.

Sony logic.

Selling less = performing better.

Judgement is not even made by the usual Gears guys.

As we've discussed before, this isn't entirely correct. Epic had a hand in the multiplayer portion. Besides, I doubt most buyers, in this case, would know who specifically developed what, making it a fairly moot point.

More importantly, neither of these two had particularly strong openings, but as prequels, you couldn't ask for/expect much more. 

"had a hand" = irrelevant. It's like saying Infinity Ward helped with MW3. Eh.. whatever shell of a staff they had lefted might have "had a hand" in it but you could clearly tell the game was made by entirely different people. Judgement is no different. Only 1 Gears head I know bought the game, the rest passed on it because "Epic isn't making it".

The whole "prequel" angle is pretty overblown on this topic by some trying to justify disappointing Ascension sales. Maybe it's the simple matter of there being loads of games out on PS3/360 in both of these franchises already and you're talking about two full priced games that could have easily been DLC.



God Of War Ascension should win over the course of the year unless Microsoft decide to bundle Gears at christmas. All the Gears games have been front loaded previously so the marginal amount it sold more in the first week will be wiped out within the first 4 weeks.



JayWood2010 said:
shakarak said:
Every Sony fan said that God of War is doing better then Gears lol. Both games did well for them being prequels and at the end of a console lifecycle.


Pretty much.  I find it hilarious that GoW numbers are actually lower in the first week but somehow people twist things around for GoW.  Sony loaylists.  I realyl dont understand you guys sometimes.

Both was prequels, both did good.  Gears had the better 1st week regardless if it isnt going to be as big as Gears 3.  news flash.  Ascension wont be as big as GoWIII

This is why most of your threads become flame war. You can't make a thread and attack a whole group of people just a few post later when you don't like the reactions. I have always questioned your intentions when I see a thread from you, stop making it so obvious.



 Next Gen 

11/20/09 04:25 makingmusic476 Warning Other (Your avatar is borderline NSFW. Please keep it for as long as possible.)

Next weeks ad for Best Buy here already had Judgment's price dropped to 49.99, God of War still full price. If judgment's price drops quickly I'd see a jump in sales.