So this is my first time playing through all 5 episodes, so PLEASE, nobody spoil anything for me. I have finished episodes 1 and 2. I'm on 3, and just got to the part where SPOILER ALERT Lily kills Carley!!!! I literally jumped out of my bed angrily cursing at Lily. I LOVED CARLEY. She was an awesome, honest and trustworthy character. WTF LILY YOU DUMB WOMAN.

What were your thoughts about Lily killing Carley? Did you take Lily with the rest of the group of leave her behind???

This game is amazing btw.

I was like WTF!!!!!!!!!!! YOU COOZE!!!!!!!!!!

But then I took her with me, anyway.

I left her behind, but when we left I already regretted that decision :(

She kills the character that you save in episode 1, telltale probably thought its too much work to work on two characters that would change in the first episode so they killed him/her in a very very lame and stupid way along with lilly.

she killed doug , I chose doug , because he is a nerd and he helped me, he was smart, carley is a dumb girl who can't place batteries on a radio, I didn't give a damn.

there are a lot of half assing in the game and thats a shame, since I loved the game so much, im hopeful for a new season.

I hated her for that, but still took her with us.
I was in shock and i needed to sort things out in my head, I planned to kick her out of the group
once we reach a safer place.......I've seen enough death.

I loaded it 5 times and tried to stop her >.

I agree. That's why it's not a legit GOTY candidate IMO. The polish is just not up to standards set by most AAA games. The cutscenes, one of the most important aspects of the game, are very choppy at times. And don't even get me started on the lip syncing...

But anyway. I choose Carley because she was good with guns. Based on how many times she saved my ass, I'd take her over that nerd Doug any day of the week :D

I choose Carley because she was pretty otherwise it would´ve been a sausage fest.

Same here. Hated her from the very beginning and for that I could finally tell her to piss off.
I also killed her father which I enjoyed very much.

I didn't like him at first, but learned his ways a bit about Lily explained that he was just very protective of his only family member left. I ended up trying to save him, and then Kenny dropped that salt lick on him and got mad at me for not taking his side...