I made this thread hoping that Nintendo and Sony fans would have a giant fight over who would win, and it would become so heated that they would force each other off the site, and thus leave Xbox gamers to reign supreme over VGChartz!!!

It was a flawless plan...but they've all been surprisingly civil. Guess I have to go back to the drawing board...

With powerups, Mario obviously, but without them Drake would win.

Nathan Drake - all he needs to do if he gets injured is to hide in cover for a few seconds and his health automatically regenerates. :o(

Depends. Mario would die because Nathan would talk nonsense all the time so mario dies of boredom. Or Nathan dies becaue Mario can do his stomp attack on Nathan before he can talk enough nonsense to kill Mario.

No weapons in this scenario.


And if its with weapons Nathan has no chance at all. Mario would use stars and POW blocks constantly Nathan would die before he could aim a gun at mario.

he's tottaly a badass character for sure! but he's kinda one dimensional compared to Nate and well mario is mario but yeah he's there too.

"Drake has to have prompts pop up on screen to know what to do"

i don't really remember having to use prompts to shoot or fight in uncharted...

anyway ot i'd go with the guy who knows how to use guns

In Uncharted 3 they pop up when a 2nd character is about to hit you.  Other stuff pops up but I forget what they're for.

That's only if you play on the easy settings.

Mario. He has that Jumbo Mushroom that makes him cray-huge. (That's a word.)