By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Website Topics - How do you feel about the performance of the VGChartz mod team?

 

How is the VGChartz mod team doing?

It's doing a great job. 299 32.97%
 
It's doing okay. 143 15.77%
 
It's not doing well. 432 47.63%
 
Total:874
Blacksaber said:
Turkish said:
Can some mod tell me in discretion when my ban statistics get reset, thanks.


Bans stay forever, the amount of days will go back down after 4-6 months (depending on mod) if your ban free from that breach (trolling, flamming, spamming ect...).


So my last ban for trolling was in june, I'll be clean next month at the earliest right?



Around the Network
NintendoPie said:
man-bear-pig said:
When can I be myself again?

Who said you couldn't be yourself?


Me. I used to be a lot more 'jokey', but I can't nowadays because the bans I get are long as fuck, and I'm afraid mods won't understand my sense of humour. E.g. Tads12 wanting to ban me for a joke post I made which he didn't understand.

Basically, when will the bans go back down to warnings so I can be me again?!



man-bear-pig said:


Me. I used to be a lot more 'jokey', but I can't nowadays because the bans I get are long as fuck, and I'm afraid mods won't understand my sense of humour. E.g. Tads12 wanting to ban me for a joke post I made which he didn't understand.

Basically, when will the bans go back down to warnings so I can be me again?!

Sometimes people can't tell when you're serious. It's hard to not report you for things like spamming my wall constantly a little while back, even though I told you to stop. Somethings that are jokes to you may be taken serious by other, you just need to make a better clarification between when you are joking or being serious.



It's tough to find the right balance. You don't want to go off and ban a dozen people, but being too light on moderation results in some really low quality posting across the board. I've recently become a big proponent of sending PMs when a poster does something that might have bothered some other users. Take the recent Kowenicki ban for example. While I don't believe his post was worthy of a ban, some other posters may have felt he was being purposely disingenuous. So in a situation like that, the best action would have been to send Kowenicki a message stating that others were bothered by his post but that he's not in trouble, and that he should only be more mindful of others in the future.

Open dialogue with members is extremely important. Warnings and bans have their place, but they can create a gap between the members and the moderation team. Posters should be given feedback on their boundaries and how their posts affect other users, and the debate should be civil. There's no perfect formula, but I think the cooperation within the current mod team will continue to produce consistent improvement.



 

 

man-bear-pig said:
Turkish said:
Can some mod tell me in discretion when my ban statistics get reset, thanks.


When the seas go dry and mountains blow in the wind like leaves

When the sun rises in the west and sets in the east. When your womb quickens and you bear a living child.

Moderation histories are not reset. We don't even have the ability to do that if we wanted to, and we don't. But if you are on good behaviour for long enough, future moderations will be less strict.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Around the Network
amp316 said:
Yoshiya said:
amp316 said:
Yoshiya said:
Blacksaber said:
Turkish said:
Can some mod tell me in discretion when my ban statistics get reset, thanks.


Bans stay forever, the amount of days will go back down after 4-6 months (depending on mod) if your ban free from that breach (trolling, flamming, spamming ect...).

So you're saying that mods use different guidelines for how harsh to treat people? That's definitely something that needs to be addressed then.

First offense is a warning, second is a day ban, third is three days, fourth is seven, and don't get in more trouble than that...

That's not what I meant. You have a system in place and according to Blacksaber you all use it differently (in the sense of how long it lasts). Isn't this the kind of thing you should at least have a standardised thing for so that people don't get less harsh treatment purely based on which mod moderated them (assuming they are on a late warning which I'll admit they are stupid to be on in the first place).

Your get a reprieve for good behavior after 6 months and the bans increase as I said.  The only time that a ban can be longer or shorter is if it is a really bad violation of the rules (longer) or a ver minor infraction (shorter).  There are definitely guidlines.

" after 4-6 months (depending on mod) " - direct quote from Blacksaber

Surely the moment the words "depending on the mod" are used to describe policy if suggests you don't have proper guidelines in place?

Just to clarify I am not discussing what each warning is worth in ban time but rather how long those warnings count towards you ban time.



NintendoPie said:
man-bear-pig said:


Me. I used to be a lot more 'jokey', but I can't nowadays because the bans I get are long as fuck, and I'm afraid mods won't understand my sense of humour. E.g. Tads12 wanting to ban me for a joke post I made which he didn't understand.

Basically, when will the bans go back down to warnings so I can be me again?!

Sometimes people can't tell when you're serious. It's hard to not report you for things like spamming my wall constantly a little while back, even though I told you to stop. Somethings that are jokes to you may be taken serious by other, you just need to make a better clarification between when you are joking or being serious.


Is that when I posted 'YOU HAVE WARTS IN YOUR VAGINA!!' on your wall like 100 times? To me, that was funny. But Moreno pm'd you and asked you to report me...which was shady, since you didn't really care...



Yoshiya said:

" after 4-6 months (depending on mod) " - direct quote from Blacksaber

Surely the moment the words "depending on the mod" are used to describe policy if suggests you don't have proper guidelines in place?

Just to clarify I am not discussing what each warning is worth in ban time but rather how long those warnings count towards you ban time.

Blacksaber is not and never has been a moderator.

The official "good behaviour" cutoff is six months, but it depends on the seriousness of the offence, the length of the mod history, and a whole host of other things. You can't have guidelines for all of that.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

man-bear-pig said:


Is that when I posted 'YOU HAVE WARTS IN YOUR VAGINA!!' on your wall like 100 times? To me, that was funny. But Moreno pm'd you and asked you to report me...which was shady, since you didn't really care...

How did you find out tha... nevermind.

Yes, that was the case. It wasn't funny to me. 



Kantor said:
man-bear-pig said:
Turkish said:
Can some mod tell me in discretion when my ban statistics get reset, thanks.


When the seas go dry and mountains blow in the wind like leaves

When the sun rises in the west and sets in the east. When your womb quickens and you bear a living child.


I'm glad someone understood that reference. Lulz