ClassicGamingWizzz said: Conegamer said: As with other threads like this, how people can downvote oblivion, mass effect 2 and 3 etc..., regarded by many as the best RPG of the gen, whilst there are still games on the list which aren't even RPG's, is beyond me. I have noted how the people who downvote it, in the majority of cases, don't even have a Wii in the first place, and, as such, can't make a subjective reason why it's the weakest RPG on the list. It's crazy. These things should have the best RPG's 'til last. That would be mass effect 2, Dark Souls, oblivion, demon souls and dragon age origins in the final 5. Let's see if that's how things pan out fixed xD   let me explain why i am downvoting xenoblade, i want mass effect 2 to win, xonoblade is number 1 right now !!!

I have no issues with your list, if you replace Skyrim with Oblivion. I prefered Skyrim greatly.

Your logic is flawed, however. For, every time you downvote Xenoblade, people who enjoy the game will upvote it instead of another game, and heck, may be petty so downvote the one you voted up. It happens (see Gilgamesh's Dev thread). So by eliminating the games on lower points, you're leaving fewer games for people to upvote and downvote, hence leading to more people downvoting Xenoblade. 

ethomaz said: Conegamer said: As with other threads like this, how people can downvote Xenoblade, regarded by many as the best RPG of the gen, whilst there are still games on the list which aren't even RPG's, is beyond me. I have noted how the people who downvote it, in the majority of cases, don't even have a Wii in the first place, and, as such, can't make a subjective reason why it's the weakest RPG on the list. It's crazy. These things should have the best RPG's 'til last. That would be Xenoblade, Dark Souls, Disgaea, Radiant Dawn and Valhalla Knights in the final 5. Let's see if that's how things pan out For me Demon's Souls and Valkyria Chronicles are better than Xenoblade but Xenoblade is a 9.x metascore for sure and one of the best in this gen . Dark Souls lost a lot about what make Demon's Souls so good... Disgaea, Radiant Dawn and Valhalla Knights I didn't play yet.

I never played Demon's Souls, but it does look real good! I've been looking for it on the cheap, but sadly I can't find it...

You should play Valhalla Knights, it's damn good! Of course, Radiant Dawn and Xenoblade are on the Wii which may be why you haven't played them, but both are kings in their RPG genres (Strategy and Japanese) respectively, and as such, deserve to stay until the end.

I have a Wii but just buy and play more games on PS3 due the Trophy system... I do not like to be playing without getting anything in return... so the Wii games I bought are for funny time with friends (New Super Mario Bros., Mario Kart, Donkey Kong Returns, Just Dance, etc).

if I find Radiant Dawn for rent I must take a chance... Xenoblade I played some hours but not finished it... it's damn good.

I suppose so. Radiant Dawn is a long game though (50 hours) so renting it wouldn't be a very good bet unless you know you're going to like it, in which case it'd probably be better to buy it (which may be cheaper anyway, it is over here!).

Xenoblade suffers a similar problem that it takes a good 5 or so hours to really get going, so it's another game which requires people to buy it, which likely limits the audience.

+ Yakuza 3
- Two Worlds

+ Arcania: Gothic 4

- Xenoblade

+ Lost Odyssey
- Blue Dragon

+ Xenoblade
- Yakuza 4

+ Xenoblade Chronicles
- Eternal Sonata

+Xenoblade
-Arcania: Gothic 4