By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - Uncharted 2 or Uncharted 3?

 

Which is better?

Uncharted 2 178 36.48%
 
Uncharted 3 174 35.66%
 
See results 136 27.87%
 
Total:488
Troll_Whisperer said:
DakonBlackblade said:
Do you have to choose btween one or another? If not get them both, and go ahead and get UC 1 as well they are all excelent games.

No I have beaten U1 and U2 several times and I'm about to get U3. I was just curious because I've seen the community a bit divided.

 

Anyway, thanks for your answers guys. I'm really looking forward to U3.



Just remember what I told you. Listen to the 'real' Uncharted gamers.

Around the Network
Jay520 said:
Troll_Whisperer said:
DakonBlackblade said:
Do you have to choose btween one or another? If not get them both, and go ahead and get UC 1 as well they are all excelent games.

No I have beaten U1 and U2 several times and I'm about to get U3. I was just curious because I've seen the community a bit divided.

 

Anyway, thanks for your answers guys. I'm really looking forward to U3.



Just remember what I told you. Listen to the 'real' Uncharted gamers.

It's ok, I was gonna play the game anyway! I already bought it.

I just wanted to hear people's opinion.

But sure, from now on I won't listen to the 'non-real' fans, if you say so. (and yes, I realise you'll kill a kitten).



No troll is too much for me to handle. I rehabilitate trolls, I train people. I am the Troll Whisperer.

U3 is definitely better, the story when compared to U2 is hard to say which is better, they're both great, but online U3 improved upon very greatly.



           

And the Oscar goes to...

Single-player: Uncharted 3 (almost tied with Uncharted 2)
Multi-player: Uncharted 3
Graphics:  Uncharted 3
Sound: Uncharted 3
Gameplay: Uncharted 3 (the new aim and meele system are better)
Story:  Uncharted 1 (Uncharted 2 and Uncharted 3 are equals)
Replay: Uncharted 3 (due the multi-player and co-op split screen)

Overall: Uncharted 3

My review notes..

9.8/10 Uncharted 3
9.7/10 Uncharted 2
9.4/10 Uncharted 1



Single-player: Uncharted 2
Multi-player: Uncharted 2
Graphics: Uncharted 2
Sound: Uncharted 2
Gameplay: Uncharted 3
Story: Uncharted 2
Replay: Uncharted 2



Around the Network
Boutros said:
Single-player: Uncharted 2
Multi-player: Uncharted 2
Graphics: Uncharted 2
Sound: Uncharted 2
Gameplay: Uncharted 3
Story: Uncharted 2
Replay: Uncharted 2

Graphics???



ethomaz said:
Boutros said:
Single-player: Uncharted 2
Multi-player: Uncharted 2
Graphics: Uncharted 2
Sound: Uncharted 2
Gameplay: Uncharted 3
Story: Uncharted 2
Replay: Uncharted 2

Graphics???

I meant how impressive the graphics were on their respective release.



Boutros said:
ethomaz said:
Boutros said:
Single-player: Uncharted 2
Multi-player: Uncharted 2
Graphics: Uncharted 2
Sound: Uncharted 2
Gameplay: Uncharted 3
Story: Uncharted 2
Replay: Uncharted 2

Graphics???

I meant how impressive the graphics were on their respective release.

Yeah... the U1 to U2 jump is way more impressive than U2 to U3 .



Uncharted 2 for the single player mode, and Uncharted 3 for the multiplayer.

You guys can say what you want, but, I've been level 75 for weeks now.. I rarely have slip-ups. The thing I hate most is when I have the most kills in the entire session, yet, still losing.. Like, how much slack do I have to carry?.

The ending in UC3 was a total disappointment, it was short, and.. There really should have been more. You don't go from boats, to planes to a dull ending. It felt rush. I think Amy procrastinated too much, honestly... And, yeah, I do it too when I write, but, at least I can say I'm on my own schedule (I'm procrastinating right now, as a matter of fact).

I'm not taking the game back, and I feel it was worth the 60 dollars, but, just barely.

But, like I said, Uncharted 3 has the better online, and polish, and Uncharted 2 has the better story.. So, it's not like one's really better than the other.. I own both, so I can play whichever, whenever (or, at least when I get UC2 back from my friends'.)



Thats pretty good, seems they are on to something.. 13 mill this gen..

Other numbers this gen.. (can't compere totally. these are not shippet, but sold to consumer)

Mariokart (wii) (1 games) 30 mill
Mario (new, galaxy i+2) (3 games) 40 mill
Halo (halo 3, reach odst) (3 games) 26 mill
Just dance 1-3 (3 games) 15,5 mill.