FUKKING REVIEWERS!

93-94. No higher.

It'll be awesome, but docked marks for being too similar.

For that, it'll not beat Skyward Sword (which I reckon 95-98), so I can't give it more than 94.

Also, Arkham City will end up around the same, when 'lower' scores (like DToid's 8.5) come flooding in.

But is that score bad? No. If you think it is, you need a reality check, my friend

I think many will drag it down from 10 because
A) Its more of the same
B) It wont have the same impact
C) Uncharted 2 had .. 96
D) The gameplay is different in terms of movement which I personally like, but for EVERYONE that LOVED Uncharted 2 to LOVE the changes.. Its not going to happen!

I've always said it'll be between 93 and 95 somewhere, but with the first reviews coming in I'm thinking closer to 95. I know it won't get 96 or higher because, although it'll likely objectively be the better game, expectations are higher and like others have said, a lot of people ARE going to complain it's 'just more of the same'.

Though i'd love to be proven wrong and have this end up being a 97% average.

95, be great if it could beat Skyward Sword, and actually gets its score of its own merits rather than franchise legacy.

Right now it looks like it will beat Skyward Sword, based on some western media responses like G4. 

I hope that by that, you meant Uncharted.

If not, all I will say, Uncharted gets a courtesy pass as much as Zelda does, and you know it.

I can see Uncharted 3 settling down somewhere between 93 - 95.

94, havent all PS3 exlusive sequels had worse scores this year?

95-97 (voted 96)

If it mets expectations (HUGE expectations by now), which I think is likely to happen, it will get the same score as Uncharted 2, but I'm hoping for a higher score. I mean, most critics will compare it with Uncharted 2 and with all PS3 exclusives of this year, and we know that Uncharted 3 can beat them easily.

If it gets a metascore lower than 92 I will be very sad ;_(

I guessed right the GT5 metacritic score, and I will again :D