First off it looks terrible. It looks like its from about 2005, 360 launch games look better.

Secondly the entire combat is motion controls so that'll be hit or miss depending on the player and if he likes motion gaming or not. 

Just look at this dude http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m1Z-P-RBzmw Like from around 2:00 on its some boss battle and she has to do is run around and then wave her arms around to swing the sword. Like yeah i guess its cool the way you swing your arms is how link uses his sword, but I don't want to play a game that's as long as Zelda with motion controls the entire time.

There's no way in hell this game will hold a candle to Ocarina of Time. Zelda is one game that should not have gone the way of motion controls. Plus its been in development about 5 years it took almost as long as GT5 to make and you get a game that's graphically not even as good as 360 launch titles?

Just forget its Zelda for a second and look at it objectively. 

First off it looks terrible. It looks like its from about 2005, 360 launch games look better.

Secondly the entire combat is motion controls so that'll be hit or miss depending on the player and if he likes motion gaming or not. 

Just look at this dude http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m1Z-P-RBzmw Like from around 2:00 on its some boss battle and she has to do is run around and then wave her arms around to swing the sword. Like yeah i guess its cool the way you swing your arms is how link uses his sword, but I don't want to play a game that's as long as Zelda with motion controls the entire time.

There's no way in hell this game will hold a candle to Ocarina of Time. Zelda is one game that should not have gone the way of motion controls. Plus its been in development about 5 years it took almost as long as GT5 to make and you get a game that's graphically not even as good as 360 launch titles?

Just forget its Zelda for a second and look at it objectively. 

you had respect for her ? xD what did she ever do that made you "ah this get must be respected!"

I think it will be a great game! It obviously is being given a lot of delicate touches to make it perfect. Has a Zelda game other than in the CD-I ever made anyone bored?

Evolution of Gameplay and Uncharted in the same sentence?

i'm i the only sane person that doesn't see how Uncharted evolved from the first game? , Cover, shoot, puzzle, repeat.

Well we don't know what Drake's Deception will be like yet but I can say for sure Among Thieves was a big change from Drake's Fortune.

Among Thieves added online elements, both competitive online (which I didn't play much of but apparently was really well done) and also co-op which I did play a fair bit of. And also it was graphically a huge improvement over Drake's Fortune. Yeah the core gamplay mechanics didn't change but really if it ain't broke don't fix it.