By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Gears of War 3 or Zelda Skyward Sword... which is more anticipated/wanted/needed?

 

Which is more highly anticipated?

Gears of War 3 60 34.88%
 
Zelda Skyward Sword 103 59.88%
 
See my tasty insides. 9 5.23%
 
Total:172

Well they are both exclusive to their respective platforms, so they are both hyped exactly the same. Apples and Oranges.



e=mc^2

Gaming on: PS4 Pro, Switch, SNES Mini, Wii U, PC (i5-7400, GTX 1060)

Around the Network
morenoingrato said:
slowmo said:
Gears for me and in all honesty, mainly as Zelda will sell to a lot of people who don't actively follow their hobby online and with pre orders. The LTD figures would be largely dependabt upon how Gears 3 reviews as Zelda will seel regardless of scores it receives where as a sub 90 score for Gears would hurt sales imo.

That is not true, Zelda fans are often more nitpickers than anybody, and even a 93 could damage it. I know that with a 89 even I would think well before getting (even if in the end I would still get it)

Zelda fans will not buy a relatively low scoring Zelda game? What?



overall gears is more hyped.



morenoingrato said:
I dunno, I mean, press is hyping Gears more, but there are never any news on Zelda, so I guess I'm not sure.

But Zelda won't outsell Gears 3 lifetime, Unless Gears doesn't have a second shipment

Lifetime sales according to VGC:

Gears 2: 6.12m
Gears 1: 5.95m

OOT: 7.6m (N64)
Twilight Princess: 5.96m (wii) and 1.56m (GCN) = 7.52m total.
LoZ: 6.51m (NES)
Multiple other Zelda's between 4 and 5m... not including VC sales.

Additionally, this is the 25th anniversary game and will be marketed as much or greater than gears3... it'll have live music concerts for christ sake.

I think there is definitely arguments that this zelda will easily eclipse Gears3, lifetime, considering its on a 90m userbase and definitely a popular IP. First week will definitely go to gears... lifetime is arguable Zelda.



superchunk said:
morenoingrato said:
I dunno, I mean, press is hyping Gears more, but there are never any news on Zelda, so I guess I'm not sure.

But Zelda won't outsell Gears 3 lifetime, Unless Gears doesn't have a second shipment

I think there is definitely arguments that this zelda will easily eclipse Gears3, lifetime, considering its on a 90m userbase and definitely a popular IP. First week will definitely go to gears... lifetime is arguable Zelda.


I think that would be the assessment most would make.  Zelda will have guaranteed legs, Gears legs will depend on how good the product is, particularly online.



Around the Network

I think majority realise this Gears is set to be much bigger and could do 5/6 million this year alone, I'd be surprised if it didn't anyway.

(0 mill Wii userbase means nothing, 90% of that userbase isn't even interested in a Zelda sort of game, whilst it will do well, WiiU is also only a year away.



 

I think Zelda, just because Gears of War has already had two titles released for it on the Xbox 360, but this is the first full console release of Zelda this generation



Skyward sword is lot less anticipated than Gear of war 3, Skyward sword will sell lot less than Gear of war 3.



Buying in 2015: Captain toad: treasure tracker,

mario maker

new 3ds

yoshi woolly world

zelda U

majora's mask 3d

I think the new gameinformer front cover and 10pages solely for ZeldaSS help prove my point that Zelda is more anticipated than GoW3.



superchunk said:

I think the new gameinformer front cover and 10pages solely for ZeldaSS help prove my point that Zelda is more anticipated than GoW3.


???? that doesnt prove anything, Gears had its own cover months ago. Its the anniversary of Zelda which is why its having so much pages, they are covering an era of the series, not just one game. Lets see some preorder numbers , THEN you we'll talk