What do you think?

Here are some possible nominees

-Modern Warfare 3

- Uncharted 3

- Gears of War 3

- Zelda Skyward sword

*Portal 2

*Only games on PS3, Xbox 360, Wii

 * No including remakes for example "Mass Effect 2"

So far Portal 2 on Xbox 360 has the highest rating according to gamerankings.

historically the safe bet would be Zelda, that series rarely goes below mid 9's, especially on consoles.

Bioshock: Infinite has a big chance

EDIT: Apperently the game will be released next year not this year.

thats comes out in 2012

Skyward sword should get pretty high, but i have a feeling reviewers will nitpick the wii motion plus.

and i hope uncharted 3 doesnt get worse reveiws then its predosessor like most PS3 exclusives are getting this year

portal 2 will have the highest metacritic if thats what you mean.

Between U3 and Zelda

Zelda, I have the feeling it will suck, dunno.

Uncharted, well, 3rd one = harsher reviewers.

No remakes :(. I was going to say Halo:CEA but I guess I can't do that now. Well, I will have to say that The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword will take the crown this year with MW3 a close second.

@Chevinator

U3 will almost certainly get lower scores than U2. It will probably still be in the 90s, but won't reach the 95/96 that U2 has.

The highest ranked game will probably be Skyward Sword or Skyrim. (Sky)

Damn! I thought it would this holiday for some reason.

I think it is going to be Skyward Sword, closely followed by Skyrim, but I wouldn't be surprised if it is the other way around