Best game

1. Uncharted 3
2. Assassin's Creed Revelations
3. Uncharted Golden Abyss

Biggest surprise game

1. FF XIII-2, quick turn around and it seems they have improved on every aspect
2. Skyrim, I only played a bit of Oblivion and didn't like, but the more I hear about this game the better it seems to get
3. Far Cry 3, looked great

Biggest dissapointment, excluding no shows (Rainbow Six, Agent, GTA, Versus, Type-0)

1. Need for Speed the Run, after Hot Pursuit I thought things were on the up, and then when they said you could get out the car I thought they have added ME like stuff and then I saw it....
2. Well I wasn't really very disappointed with many other things...

Top 3 Games of E3

1.Battlefield 3

2.Uncharted 3

3.Skyrim

Top 3 games

1. Battlefield 3
2. Uncharted 3
3. Mass Effect 3

Top 3 surprises
1. Vita launch price
2. WiiU mature games
3. Far Cry 3

Best game of E3
1º Uncharted 3
2º Skyrim
3º Dust 514

The biggest game surprise of E3:
1º Dragon's Crown
2º Dust 514
3º Payday: The HEIST

Most dissapoint game of E3:
1º FF 13-2 (I want Versus XIII)
2º Some Kinect games
3º Some Move games

Best Games
1. Skyrim
2. Battlefield 3
3. Bioshock Infinite

Biggest suprises
1. Starhawk
2. Tomb Raider (ill assume the final version will have far less moaning as no doubt a lot of people have been voicingtheir complaints)
3. Far Cry 3

Most Disappointing (For Games I thought I would care about.)
1. Need for Speed Run
2. Ryse
3. Uncharted 3 (Dead Space 2 and Vanquish have spoiled my tps expectations. Best graphics ever is not enough. Its still going to be a great game and I'm still going to be getting it, but I have lost a lot of hype for it since its been announced)

In the future if you want something moved please message a mod, unlikely to happen if you just toss it in the thread.  You got lucky this time though.

OT:

Best:

1) Journey
2) Catherine
3) Uncharted 3

Surprise:

1) FF XIII-2 (I'm hearing a lot of things I like to hear, might get the taste of X-2 out of my mouth)
2) Pixeljunk Sidescroller (I was apprehensive about the idea but I quite enjoyed what I played)
3) Pixeljunk Lifelike (not sure it's a good surprise but that was seriously weird)

Dissapointment: 

1) absensce of The Last Guardian
2) Dead Island (game looks like it'll end up great but that was a terrible demo for it on the floor, 5 minutes from the start of that kind of game shows you next to nothing)
3) Sony's conference in general (wanted more announcements for PS3 and less video of stuff we've already seen/move working on stuff that's already anounced)

Top 3

1. Mass Effect 3

2. Halo 4

3. Dance Central 2

Best:

1. Skyrim (that 14 min demo OMFG! so amazing)
2. Uncharted 3
3. Battlefeild 3 or mabye Bioshock...hard to choose

Surprise:

1. Wii U
2. Sly 4
3. 249$ PSV price

Disappointment:

1. No agent
2. No Last Guardian
3. No FF Versus XIII

Top games
1. SSX
2. Star Wars The Old Republic
3. Final Fantasy XIII-2
Biggest Surprises
1.Vita Launch Price
2. Good new 3rd party console games will be on Vita as well.
3. Cross game voice chat for Vita
Biggest Disappointment
1. No Sorcery
2. No price cut for PS3
3. The Wii U (at first i was hyped, but the more i think about his console the disappointed i become)

Best games of E3 :

1. Halo 4 (yes I know there wasn't any actual gameplay but that doesn't make it any less awesome for me!)

2. Mass effect 3

3. Skyrim

The biggest game surprises of E3 ( games you dont expect to be good but totally rock ):

1. Skyrim

2. 

Most dissapointing games of E3:

1.